Computational and Inferential Tools for Machine Learning Methods in Biostatistical Research

现代机器学习方法，如Boosting、支持向量机或神经网络，主要在提高预测和预测精度方面对统计研究和应用产生了巨大影响。它们模拟复杂相互作用和非线性效应的能力增强，也可以用来解释潜在的物理或生理现象，并为进一步研究产生具体的科学假说。然而，在非严格预测应用中，许多现代方法的使用因其黑箱性质和缺乏推理工具而受到阻碍，这些工具将允许获得关于推断关系的统计置信度衡量。最简单的统计推断在经典模型中是普遍的，它与关于单个协变量的陈述有关。例如，协变量“性别”是疾病发展模型中的一个重要因素吗？在经典模型中，这是通过计算与模型中的“性别”相关的一个参数(或一小组参数)的统计推理量(p值，可信区间)来回答的。相比之下，机器学习方法使用非参数方法，其中协变量对结果的影响不受一小部分参数的控制。因此，经典的方法是不适用的，任何特定协变量在结果模型中的重要性都不容易检验。虽然已经提出了许多特定于模型或近似的度量，特别是随机森林模型中的可变重要性度量，但在文献中还没有通用的、统计上一致的方法。我们建议以免费可用的软件包的形式开发、验证、应用和传播一套用于经典推理的工具，这些工具将允许研究人员测试结果的非参数机器学习模型中感兴趣的协变量的重要性和影响。

Modern machine learning methods, such as boosting, support vector machines, or neural networks, have made great impact on statistical research and application mostly in terms of improved predictive and prognostic accuracy. Their enhanced abilities to model complex interactions and non-linear effects could also be utilized to explain the underlying physical or physiological phenomena and to generate specific scientific hypothesis for further study. In non-strictly predictive applications, use of many modern methods, however, is hampered by their black-box nature and by the lack of inferential tools that would allow to obtain statistical confidence measures on inferred relationships. The simplest statistical inference which is universal in classical models pertains to statements on individual covariates. For example, is covariate "Gender" an important factor in a model of disease progression? In classical models this is answered by calculating statistical inference quantities (p-values, confidence intervals) on a parameter (or small set of parameters) that are connected with "Gender" in a model. In contrast, machine learning methods utilize a non-parametric approach where covariates influence on the outcome is not controlled by a small set of parameters. Hence the classical approach is not applicable and an importance of any particular covariate in the model of the outcome is not easily tested. While many model-specific or approximate measures have been proposed, in particular Variable Importance Metric in a Random Forest model, there is no universal, statistically coherent approach present in literature. We propose to develop, validate, apply and disseminate - in the form of freely available software packages - a set of tools for classical inference that will allow researchers to test the importance and influence of covariates of interest in the non-parametric machine learning models of the outcome.