COLLABORATIVE RESEARCH: Fitting More Pieces into the Puzzle of Judicial Behavior: A Multi-Country Data Base and Program of Research

合作研究：将更多内容纳入司法行为之谜：多国数据库和研究计划

• 批准号: 9975315
• 负责人: C.Neal Tate
• 金额: $ 4.5万
• 依托单位: University of North Texas
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 项目类别: Standard Grant
• 财政年份: 1999
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 1999-10-01 至 2002-09-30
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=9975315&HistoricalAwards=false
• 关键词: COLLABORATIVE; RESEARCH; Fitting; More; Pieces

The objective of the project is to encourage the expansion of systematic comparative analyses of courts, judges and their behavior based on replicable data. This project will eventuate in a multi-country data base that will (1) focus on the top courts from a manageable most different systems sample of nations, (2) select annual samples of their formal or reported decisions over a half century, (3) code the manifest content of the opinions accompanying the sampled decisions according to a master codebook, measure a set of common variables that are relevant to various analytical interests and that can be equivalently measured across all included nations, and (4) supplement the common variables by coding a set of system-specific variables that might not be measured across all nations.These data will be created and archived for public use. However, the P.I.s also will use them to analyze an important set of initial research questions, including (1) do these and other courts regularly decide cases with apparently important policy consequences, or do most of them spend most of their time resolving legal disputes of only narrow policy significance?, (2) Do "the haves in fact always come out ahead"? (3) Do judicial independence, functional performance, and support of incumbent regimes by national courts vary with political transitions, proclaimed national crises or with executive appointments of sympathetic judges?

该项目的目标是鼓励根据可复制的数据，扩大对法院、法官及其行为的系统比较分析。该项目最终将形成一个多国数据库，该数据库将：(1)从可管理的最不同的国家系统样本中集中于最高法院；(2)选择半个世纪以来其正式或报告的裁决的年度样本；(3)根据主编码本对抽样决定附带的意见的明显内容进行编码；(3)测量一组与各种分析利益相关的共同变量，并可在所有纳入的国家中进行同等测量；(4)通过对一组可能不能在所有国家测量的特定系统变量进行编码来补充公共变量。这些数据将被创建并存档供公众使用。然而，私家侦探们也将利用它们来分析一组重要的初步研究问题，包括(1)这些法院和其他法院是否定期裁决具有明显重要政策后果的案件，或者它们中的大多数是否将大部分时间花在解决仅具有狭隘政策意义的法律纠纷上？(2)“有钱人实际上总是领先的”吗？(3)司法独立、职能表现和国家法院对现任政权的支持是否会随着政治过渡、宣布的国家危机或行政任命同情的法官而有所不同？