Citizen-Science Alliances in Contested Environmental Diseases

有争议的环境疾病的公民科学联盟

• 批准号: 9975518
• 负责人: Phil Brown
• 金额: $ 8.41万
• 依托单位: Brown University
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 项目类别: Continuing Grant
• 财政年份: 2000
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2000-07-01 至 2003-06-30
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=9975518&HistoricalAwards=false
• 关键词: Citizen; Science; Alliances; Contested; Environmental

This project examines citizen-science alliances that deal with "contested illnesses" that involve major scientific disputes and extensive public debates over environmental causes. Focusing on three major disputes -- Gulf War Syndrome, small air particles and asthma, and environmental factors in breast cancer - this project examines research collaborations between laypeople and scientists, either as individual scientists or as part of research groups or institutes, that identify, determine causes of, and plan remediation of, contested environmental illnesses. For each area, this project will examine the following questions: 1) How do laypeople decide they need science allies and seek them out? 2) Where are allies found? 3) How do scientists who serve as allies think about their role? 4) How successful are the processes and outcomes of citizen-science alliances? 5) Do science allies face discouragement, condemnation, or bias as a result of their activities? 6) Should policymakers and regulatory agencies create new organizational contexts, based on laypeople's experiences, that will provide science allies? Data include state and federal government documents involved in setting up the Long Island Breast Cancer study, the Silent Spring Institute, the Massachusetts Toxic Use Reduction Institute, and the VA-sponsored Gulf War research centers, as well as EPA documents on its small air particles conference. Interviews will be conducted with citizen activists, scientists, and government officials involved in the three contested illnesses, as well as with researchers at organizations that provide various forms of research aid to citizens. Site-based observation will be carried out at Silent Spring Institute (breast cancer), Boston Environmental Hazard Center (Gulf War illnesses), Action for Community and Environment (asthma), and Toxic Use Reduction Institute. Results will expand existing knowledge of public participation in science and of transformations in scientific methods. By understanding public reactions, policy makers can be prepared for similar issues in the future. This project includes substantial support for graduate students to assist with this component of the research, which is part of a related larger project funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Results will be reported at meetings and in journals; a book is also planned.

这个项目考察了处理“有争议的疾病”的公民科学联盟，这些疾病涉及重大的科学争议和对环境原因的广泛的公众辩论。该项目聚焦于三个主要争议——海湾战争综合症、空气微粒和哮喘以及乳腺癌中的环境因素——该项目考察了非专业人士和科学家之间的研究合作，无论是作为个体科学家还是作为研究小组或研究所的一部分，他们都能识别、确定有争议的环境疾病的原因，并制定补救计划。对于每个领域，本项目将研究以下问题：1)外行人如何决定他们需要科学盟友并寻找他们？2)同盟在哪里？3)作为盟友的科学家如何看待自己的角色？4)公民科学联盟的过程和结果有多成功？5)科学同盟是否因其活动而面临挫折、谴责或偏见？6)决策者和监管机构是否应该基于外行人的经验创造新的组织环境，从而提供科学盟友？数据包括州和联邦政府文件，这些文件涉及建立长岛乳腺癌研究、寂静的春天研究所、马萨诸塞州减少有毒物质使用研究所和va赞助的海湾战争研究中心，以及EPA关于空气微粒会议的文件。采访对象包括参与这三种有争议疾病的公民活动家、科学家和政府官员，以及为公民提供各种形式研究援助的组织的研究人员。将在寂静之春研究所（乳腺癌）、波士顿环境危害中心（海湾战争疾病）、社区与环境行动（哮喘）和减少有毒物质使用研究所进行现场观察。结果将扩大公众参与科学和科学方法转变的现有知识。通过了解公众的反应，政策制定者可以为未来类似的问题做好准备。该项目包括对研究生的大量支持，以协助研究的这一部分，这是由罗伯特伍德约翰逊基金会资助的一个相关的更大项目的一部分。结果将在会议和期刊上报告；还计划出一本书。