Doctoral Dissertation Research: The Social Re-Discovery of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances

博士论文研究：全氟烷基和多氟烷基物质的社会重新发现

• 批准号: 1738687
• 负责人: Phil Brown
• 金额: $ 0.78万
• 依托单位: Northeastern University
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 项目类别: Standard Grant
• 财政年份: 2017
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2017-06-01 至 2018-11-30
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1738687&HistoricalAwards=false
• 关键词: Doctoral; Dissertation; Research; Social; Re

This project will analyze the social discovery of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs). In production since the 1950s, this group of chemicals are used in consumer products, industrial surfactants, and fire-fighting foam. Despite decades of use, the potential toxicity and scope of contamination of PFASs were not known to the U.S. public, military, or regulatory agencies until the early 2000s. This project will examine the discovery and re-discovery of PFASs by individuals, stakeholder groups, litigants, and scientists over six decades of mass production. Inherent in any discovery are questions about prior ignorance; this project traces the ways in which regulatory frameworks produced scientific ignorance pertaining to the effects of PFASs on humans and the environment. Therefore, in addition to identifying the production of scientific knowledge regarding the risks of PFASs, this project traces the ways in which current regulatory frameworks produce scientific ignorance pertaining to environmental exposures and human toxicity of PFASs. Sociological investigation of this kind will find similarities and differences in social discovery processes and track stakeholder behavior. The project questions why scientific discovery about the effects of PFAFs that began in the 1960s did not take shape until the late 2000s, despite the decades-long discovery of contamination in workers, wildlife, and eventually the blood of the entire global population. This project will use participant observation, in-depth interviews, and archival document analysis to account for this unexpected and uneven discovery process. The methodology includes seven months of participant observation at multiple sites to learn how scientists, industry, regulators, and contaminated communities respond to PFASs. Semi-structured interviews will be conducted. The intent will be to examine how scientific research, corporate action, and lay activism began, and how stakeholders produce and translate scientific data into informed regulatory decisions. Recent research emphasizes that isolating a single cause of a latent health outcome reflects a scientific and regulatory logic that fails to comprehend the novelty of chemical exposure. Dominant regulatory data collection norms, risk management frameworks, and legal paths of recourse do not align with the non-linear pathways, intergenerational timelines, and often latent forms of harm that arise from chronic chemical exposure. Sociology is uniquely positioned to identify such incongruent logics, and thus can assist in pulling apart values, assumptions, and incentives to clarify and re-imagine more adaptive organizational forms. This project will contribute to the growing number of social science studies on chemical policy, facilitating future comparison across social science studies of chemicals and chemical classes.

该项目将分析全氟烷基和多氟烷基物质（PFAS）的社会发现。自20世纪50年代以来，这组化学品用于消费品，工业表面活性剂和消防泡沫。尽管使用了几十年，但PFAS的潜在毒性和污染范围直到21世纪初才为美国公众、军方或监管机构所知。该项目将研究个人，利益相关者团体，诉讼当事人和科学家在六十年的大规模生产中发现和重新发现PFAS。在任何发现中固有的是关于先前无知的问题;该项目追踪了监管框架产生有关PFASs对人类和环境影响的科学无知的方式。因此，除了确定有关PFAS风险的科学知识的产生之外，该项目还追踪了当前监管框架如何产生有关PFAS环境暴露和人体毒性的科学无知。这种社会学研究将发现社会发现过程的相似性和差异性，并跟踪利益相关者的行为。该项目质疑为什么从20世纪60年代开始的关于PFAF影响的科学发现直到21世纪末才形成，尽管数十年来在工人，野生动物以及最终整个全球人口的血液中发现了污染。这个项目将使用参与者观察，深入访谈和档案文件分析，以解释这个意想不到的和不平衡的发现过程。该方法包括在多个地点进行为期七个月的参与观察，以了解科学家，行业，监管机构和受污染社区如何应对PFAS。 将进行半结构化面试。 其目的是研究科学研究，企业行动和非专业行动是如何开始的，以及利益相关者如何产生科学数据并将其转化为明智的监管决策。最近的研究强调，孤立一个潜在的健康结果的单一原因反映了一个科学和监管逻辑，未能理解化学品暴露的新奇。 主要的监管数据收集规范、风险管理框架和法律的追索途径与非线性途径、代际时间表以及慢性化学品暴露引起的潜在危害形式不一致。 社会学在识别这种不一致的逻辑方面具有独特的地位，因此可以帮助我们将价值观、假设和激励机制分开，以澄清和重新想象更具适应性的组织形式。该项目将促进越来越多的关于化学品政策的社会科学研究，促进未来对化学品和化学品类别的社会科学研究的比较。

项目成果

Non-stick science: Sixty years of research and (in)action on fluorinated compounds

• DOI: 10.1177/0306312718799960
• 发表时间: 2018-10-01
• 期刊: SOCIAL STUDIES OF SCIENCE
• 影响因子: 3
• 作者: Richter, Lauren;Cordner, Alissa;Brown, Phil
• 通讯作者: Brown, Phil