Distingushing Principles from Prejudice in American's Views on Racial Policy
Distingushing Principles from Prejudice in American's Views on Racial Policy
批准号:
0318800
负责人:
Leonie Huddy
金额:
$34.21万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2003
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2003-06-01 至 2006-06-30
中文摘要
种族问题上的冲突已经成为美国社会的主要政治分歧之一,政府消除经济福祉中种族差异的努力仍然备受争议。公交车、积极的大学招生计划、将政府合同授予少数族裔企业的努力、Head Start午餐计划以及其他种族计划都引起了强烈反对。为了更好地理解目前围绕政府在种族问题上的行动的公众争议,调查人员调查了两种相互矛盾的解释,以解释对种族政策的广泛反对。第一本书考察了源于个人主义和对有限政府的支持的政治意识形态中的反对意见;第二本书探讨了种族偏见的作用。到目前为止,对于这两种解释中哪一种最能解释反对种族政策的原因,目前还没有达成共识。这个项目的目标是比过去的研究更全面地解决这一争议。在过去经验研究的基础上,发展了一种广泛的方法来解决这个问题,但大大扩大了研究的范围。两种分析方法被融合在一起,这两种分析方法在过去的研究中被用来理清种族态度的起源:对横断面数据的多变量分析,以及通常嵌入调查工具的实验设计。多变量方法试图在统计上区分偏见和原则对种族政策偏好的影响,尽管这项技术的成功在很大程度上取决于用于评估概念的措施的概念状态。种族态度的衡量一直特别有争议,破坏了人们对证据的广泛接受,这些证据表明,种族怨恨和“新”种族主义的其他衡量标准预示着种族政策的反对。相比之下,实验方法通常会改变种族项目受益者的性质和质量,但可能会导致对关键发现的解释不同。研究人员依靠实验-多变量相结合的方法来发挥两种方法的优势,在这种方法中,他们通过实验改变一组种族方案,并使用多变量测试分析结果。这意味着,例如,只有当种族偏见的规模导致对有利于黑人而不是白人或其他群体成员的计划的反对时,他们才会推断存在偏见反对。本研究利用这一综合实验-多变量方法,在两波全国电话调查的背景下,评估支持一套不同种族政策的意识形态和偏见基础。样本是基于对第一波中1400名白人和400名黑人受访者的采访;在第二波中,将尝试对所有最初的受访者进行重新采访。第一波数据收集将评估人们对一系列种族政策实验的反应,其中包括一系列涉及各种意识形态原则的问题。第二波将专注于为不同的种族群体复制相同的政策实验,以提供强大的受试者内部数据,这些数据将补充第一波政策实验的反应。在实验中,他们操纵一系列政治原则,并检查针对黑人、白人和其他群体成员的计划的支持情况。此外,他们还探讨政治原则对所有目标群体的影响,以评估其各自的影响。从更广泛的角度来看,这项研究将扩大政策制定者对种族政策态度的理解--这是当代社会中一个潜在的分裂因素,随着美国在未来几十年变得越来越多样化,这一因素可能会加深。这项研究探索了各种各样的种族政策替代方案,将为我们清楚地了解哪些种族政策获得了最多美国人的支持。
英文摘要
Conflict over racial issues has become one of the major political cleavages in American society and government attempts to eradicate racial differences in financial well being remained highly controversial. Busing, affirmative college admission programs, efforts to award government contracts to minority-owned businesses, the Head Start lunch program, and other racial programs have aroused heated opposition. To better understand the public controversy that currently surrounds government action on racial matters, the investigators examine two competing explanations for broad opposition to racial policies. The first examines opposition grounded in political ideology that stems from individualism and support for limited government; the second explores the role of racial prejudice. There is no consensus, as yet, on which of these two explanations best accounts for opposition to racial policies. The goal in this project is to resolve this controversy more fully than has been accomplished by past research. A broad approach to the problem is developed that builds on past empirical studies, but widens the scope of research considerably. Two analytic methods are melded that have been used in past research to disentangle the origins of racial attitudes: multivariate analyses of cross-sectional data, and experimental designs typically embedded within a survey instrument. Multivariate methods attempt to statistically distinguish between the effects of prejudice and principles on racial policy preferences, although the success of the technique depends heavily on the conceptual status of the measures used to assess a concept. The measurement of racial attitudes has been especially controversial, undermining broad acceptance of evidence that racial resentment and other measures of the "new" racism predict racial policy opposition. In contrast, experimental methods have typically varied the nature and qualities of racial program beneficiaries, but can lead to differences in interpretation of key findings. The investigators build on the strengths of both approaches by relying on a combined experimental-multivariate approach in which they vary a set of racial programs experimentally and analyze the results using multivariate tests. This means, for example, that they infer the existence of prejudicial opposition only when scales of racial prejudice result in opposition to programs that benefit blacks but not whites or members of other groups. The current study draws on this combined experimental -multivariate approach to assess the ideological and prejudicial basis of support for a diverse set of racial polices within the context of a two-wave national telephone survey. The sample is based on interviews with 1,400 white and 400 black respondents in the first wave; re-interviews will be attempted with all initial respondents in the second wave. The first wave of data collection will assess reactions to a series of racial policy experiments and include a set of questions that tap various ideological principles. The second wave will focus on replication of the same policy experiments for different racial groups to provide powerful within-subjects data that will complement reactions to the policy experiments in wave 1. Within the experiments, they manipulate a series of political principles, and examine support for the programs when targeted at blacks, whites, and members of other groups. Moreover, they explore the impact of political principles across the full range of target groups to assess their respective effects. From a broader perspective, this research will extend policy makers' understanding of racial policy attitudes - a potentially divisive factor within contemporary society that may deepen as the United States becomes increasingly diverse over the next several decades. The exploration in this research of a broad variety of racial policy alternatives will provide clear insight into the kinds of racial policies that garner most support from Americans.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Small Grant for Exploratory Research: Americans Respond to Hurricane Katrina
-
批准号:0555068
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$6.35万
-
财政年份:2005
-
负责人:Leonie Huddy
-
依托单位:
SGER: The Dynamic, Multi-Faceted Effects of Threat on U.S. Domestic and Foreign Policy Attitudes
-
批准号:0201650
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$5.0万
-
财政年份:2001
-
负责人:Leonie Huddy
-
依托单位:
Acquisition of an Experimental Survey Research Laboratory in the Social Sciences at SUNY, Stony Brook
-
批准号:9977503
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$10.49万
-
财政年份:1999
-
负责人:Leonie Huddy
-
依托单位:
POWRE: Political Identification as Social Identity: The Portrayal of Feminists and the Development of Feminist Identity
-
批准号:9805892
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$5.0万
-
财政年份:1998
-
负责人:Leonie Huddy
-
依托单位:
国内基金
海外基金
基于First Principles的光催化降解PPCPs同步脱氮体系构建及其电子分配机制研究
-
批准号:51778175
-
项目类别:面上项目
-
资助金额:59.0万元
-
批准年份:2017
-
负责人:丁杰
-
依托单位: