When Ecphory Fails: Secondary Processes in Eyewitness Identification
When Ecphory Fails: Secondary Processes in Eyewitness Identification
批准号:
0850401
负责人:
Gary Wells
金额:
$40.71万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2009
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2009-07-01 至 2015-05-31
中文摘要
警方对目击者的错误辨认是对无辜者定罪的主要原因。心理学科学家开发的阵容的改进使法律系统受益。但是,进一步的改进需要更好地理解次级过程所起的作用。与主要过程(识别记忆)不同,次要过程缓慢、费力、深思熟虑、可用语言表达,而且基本上对罪犯是否在首发阵容中不敏感。这些次级过程包括推论、演绎、排除过程、相对判断和其他形式的推理。次要过程被假设为在主要过程失败时进行,并可能导致灾难性的肯定识别决定。共进行了六个实验(总计N=2400),在这些实验中,人们观看模拟的犯罪,并试图从存在罪犯或移除罪犯的阵容中进行识别。每个实验都经过精心设计,在一半的条件下导致识别失败,以研究次级过程的参与。两个实验在记忆获得级别上操纵识别体验的失败(例如,使它们中的一些人对所目睹的事件有较差的看法),两个实验在记忆存储级别上操纵识别体验的失败(例如,操纵观看和排列之间的时间流逝),以及两个实验在记忆检索级别上操纵识别体验(例如,颗粒状的、低分辨率的排列任务)。在排除罪犯的条件下,证人将识别转移到填充者(而不是不识别)的倾向被预测为在导致识别失败的条件下最大。此外,研究了参与者证人的言语表达,以更多地了解映射到这些识别错误的次级过程的性质。这些发现可以帮助我们开发更好的阵容程序,并在发生错误识别时更好地诊断。
英文摘要
Mistaken eyewitness identification from police lineups is the primary cause of the conviction of innocent people. Improvements to lineups developed by psychological scientists have benefitted the legal system. But, further improvements require a better understanding of the role played by secondary processes. Unlike the primary process (recognition memory) secondary processes are slow, effortful, deliberative, verbalizable, and largely insensitive to whether or not the culprit is in the lineup. These secondary processes include inferences, deductions, elimination processes, relative judgments, and other forms of reasoning. Secondary processes are hypothesized to be engaged when the primary process fails and can lead to disastrous affirmative identification decisions. Six experiments (total N=2400) are conducted in which people view a simulated crime and attempt an identification from either a culprit-present or a culprit-removed lineup. Each experiment is carefully designed to induce a failure of recognition in one-half of the conditions so as to study the engagement of secondary processes. Two experiments manipulate failure of the recognition experience at the level of memory acquisition (e.g., giving some of them a poor view of the witnessed event), two experiments manipulate failure of the recognition experience at the level of memory storage (e.g., manipulating the passage of time between viewing and the lineup), and two experiments manipulate the recognition experience at the level of memory retrieval (e.g., a grainy, low-resolution lineup task). The tendency of witnesses in culprit-removed lineup conditions to shift identifications to fillers (rather than making no identification) is predicted to be greatest in the conditions that induce recognition failure. In addition, the verbalizations of participant witnesses are studied to learn more about the nature of the secondary processes that map into these identification errors. The findings can help us develop better lineup procedures and better diagnose when mistaken identifications occur.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Self-Propelled Droplet Motion on Gradient Slippery Liquid Infused Porous Surfaces (G-SLIPS)
-
批准号:EP/P026613/1
-
项目类别:Research Grant
-
资助金额:$12.62万
-
财政年份:2017
-
负责人:Gary Wells
-
依托单位:
Collaborative Research: Understanding and Predicting Eyewitness Identification Errors: Studies Using a Unique Set of Materials from Actual Lineups
-
批准号:1420181
-
项目类别:Continuing Grant
-
资助金额:$26.34万
-
财政年份:2014
-
负责人:Gary Wells
-
依托单位:
Eyewitnesses' Retrospective Reports on External Influences
-
批准号:0647243
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$25.0万
-
财政年份:2007
-
负责人:Gary Wells
-
依托单位:
Eyewitness Identification: Debiasing the Effects of Composites and Surveillance Images
-
批准号:0211711
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$33.0万
-
财政年份:2002
-
负责人:Gary Wells
-
依托单位:
Post-identification Feedback to Eyewitnesses: Psychological Processes and Forensic Consequences
-
批准号:9807339
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$28.57万
-
财政年份:1998
-
负责人:Gary Wells
-
依托单位:
Eyewitness Identification Confidence and Ecphoric Judgments
-
批准号:9308275
-
项目类别:Continuing Grant
-
资助金额:$27.3万
-
财政年份:1993
-
负责人:Gary Wells
-
依托单位:
The Selection of Distractors and Eyewitness Identification Accuracy
-
批准号:9022182
-
项目类别:Continuing Grant
-
资助金额:$17.7万
-
财政年份:1991
-
负责人:Gary Wells
-
依托单位: