课题基金 / 基金详情

Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: Vote-Buying and Political Preferences in Africa

Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: Vote-Buying and Political Preferences in Africa
政治学博士论文研究:非洲的买票和政治偏好
批准号:
1122700
负责人:
Daniel Posner
金额:
$1.18万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2011
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2011-09-01 至 2012-08-31

项目摘要

项目成果

Daniel Posner的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
政治人物在竞选期间向选民分配少量物质资源,通常是以金钱、食物、啤酒或衣服的形式分配,这在世界各地的许多民主国家一直很常见。这些活动通常被称为收买选票。在投票保密没有立法或执行的地方,买票可能是有效的,因为政客们可以强制执行收买选票的交易。然而,在某些情况下,尽管进行了无记名投票,收买选票的现象依然存在。在肯尼亚,一些地区超过40%的选民在2007年选举前收到了钱;然而,投票在形式上是秘密的,政党缺乏监督选民的能力,而且绝大多数人认为,有权势的人无法弄清楚他们是如何投票的。在肯尼亚收买选票令人费解。这甚至更令人费解,因为非洲人,尤其是肯尼亚人,经常被认为是按种族投票的。如果非洲选民像传统智慧所说的那样按种族投票,为什么他们的选票也要被收买呢?为了理解非洲背景下的投票购买,这个项目发展了对投票购买如何影响接受者和观察者的偏好和期望的更全面的理解。事实上,尽管在许多情况下收买选票的现象很普遍,但几乎没有系统的证据证明它对政客的支持和看法产生了影响。这个项目提供了这样的证据,同时解决了基本上未回答的问题:收买选票在为政客赢得支持方面有效吗?如果是这样的话,收买选票对谁有效?为什么?至少有两个原因,用调查数据很难回答这些问题。首先,由于尴尬或恐惧,许多受访者不愿诚实地回答有关买票的调查问题,这会使调查产生偏见。其次,不同的选票收买理论预测的结果在调查数据中观察到的结果是相同的。为了避免这些问题,本研究在肯尼亚进行了实地实验。这些实验将向参与者呈现人造的、但现实的、讨论假想政治候选人的录音,只是在随机选择的试验组听到的录音中包含了对政客收买选票行为的微妙引用。后续问题将衡量对录音中讨论的政客的支持和看法,并将产生一个数据集,用来分析和衡量收买选票对选民对政客的支持和看法在多个关键维度上的影响。实验的人为因素为检验相互竞争的理论提供了必要的控制。此外,录音的使用使调查人员能够在提到收买选票时获得微妙的信息。这一项目的学术价值在于它有能力促进对非洲选举的关键民主进程的工作方式的了解。该项目特别说明了普遍而令人费解的收买选票现象。通过帮助我们了解收买选票是否有效以及为什么有效,该项目增强了人们对民主选举何时以及为什么能够--以及为什么--产生响应性和负责任的政府的了解。该项目的更广泛影响与其智力贡献有关。该项目可以为旨在促进政府对其公民的响应和问责的政策和方案的设计提供信息。
英文摘要
The distribution of small material resources by politicians to voters during election campaigns, often in the form of money, food, beer, or clothing, has long been common in many democracies around the world. These activities typically go by the name of vote buying. Where ballot secrecy is not legislated or enforced, buying votes can be effective because politicians can enforce vote-buying bargains. In some settings, however, vote-buying persists despite the secret ballot. In Kenya, over 40 percent of voters in some areas received money before the 2007 election; yet the ballot is formally secret, parties lack the capacity to monitor voters, and large majorities believe that powerful people cannot figure out how they voted. Vote buying in Kenya is puzzling. It is even more puzzling because Africans and Kenyans in particular are often said to vote ethnically. If African voters vote ethnically, as the conventional wisdom suggests, why must their votes also be bought? To understand vote buying in the African context, this project develops a fuller understanding of how vote buying influences the preferences and expectations of recipients and observers. Indeed, despite the prevalence of vote-buying in many settings, there is little systematic evidence documenting its impact on support for and perceptions of politicians. This project provides such evidence while addressing largely unanswered questions: Is vote buying effective in building support for politicians? If so, with whom is vote buying effective, and why? Answering these questions is difficult with survey data for at least two reasons. First, because of embarrassment or fear, many survey respondents are unwilling to respond honestly to survey questions about vote buying, which biases the surveys. Second, different theories of vote buying predict outcomes that are observationally equivalent in survey data. To avoid these problems, this study conducts field experiments in Kenya. The experiments will present participants with artificial, but realistic, audio recordings discussing hypothetical political candidates, varying only the inclusion of subtle references to the politician's vote-buying behavior in the recordings heard by randomly selected treatment groups. Follow-up questions will gauge support for and perceptions of the politicians discussed in the recording, and will yield a dataset with which to analyze and measure vote buying's impact on voter support for and perceptions of politicians across a number of key dimensions. The artificiality of the experiment provides the control necessary to test competing theories. Moreover, the use of recordings allows the investigator to gain subtlety in referring to vote buying. The intellectual merit of this project lies in its capacity to advance understanding of the workings of the critical democratic process of elections in Africa. The project illuminates in particular the widespread and puzzling phenomenon of vote buying. By contributing to our understanding of whether and why vote buying is effective, the project enhances knowledge of when and why democratic elections do--and do not--yield responsive and accountable government.The broader implications of the project are tied to its intellectual contributions. The project can inform the design of policies and programs seeking to promote the responsiveness and accountability of governments to their citizens.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
DDRIG in DRMS: The Effects of Internalized Cultural Inferiority on Political Attitudes and Behavior
Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: Voter Expectations of Candidates in Parliamentary Elections in the Middle East
Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: Distinguishing Religious and Ethnic Politics in Africa
Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: Ethnicity and Retrospection: Explaining Voting Behavior in Uganda
海外基金