Logical consequence. Epistemological and proof-theoretic perspectives.
Logical consequence. Epistemological and proof-theoretic perspectives.
批准号:
206616311
负责人:
Dr. Luca Tranchini
金额:
$0.0万
依托单位国家:
德国
项目类别:
Research Grants
财政年份:
2012
资助国家:
德国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2011-12-31 至 2014-12-31
中文摘要
塔斯基对逻辑结果关系的传统分析是从真理的角度来解释结果的。达格·普拉维茨(Dag Prawitz)最近提出了一种与之竞争的观点,旨在用证明的概念取代真理的概念。这两种方法的共同点是将结果定性为“传递”:当且仅当真理时,B是a的逻辑结果。这两种对逻辑结果的分析都是关于如何理解语言句子意义的不同观点的核心。真理论的解释根据一个句子为真所必须具备的条件来描述它的意义。证明论的方法试图根据证明它或说,认识它是什么来描述一个句子的意义,与真理论的方法相反,它是建立在一个超越认识的真理概念上的。我们认为,被封装在标准证明理论方法中的结果传递观,破坏了发展出一种真正替代基于真理的方法的可能性。该研究旨在发展一种替代的证明理论方法,该方法基于对结果的“传递”观点的拒绝,能够产生一种基于主体认识论能力的意义概念。关键词:逻辑推论,证明语义学,意义理论
英文摘要
The traditional analysis of the relation of logical consequence due to Alfred Tarski explains consequence in terms of truth. A more recent rival view developed by Dag Prawitz aims at replacing the notion of truth with the one of proof. What is common to both approaches is the characterization of consequence as 'transmission': B is a logical consequence of A if and only if truth (resp. provability) is transmitted from A to B.Both analyses of logical consequence are the core of alternative views on how the meaning of the sentences of a language is to be conceived. The truththeoretic account characterizes the meaning of a sentence in terms of the conditions that must obtain for it to be true. The proof-theoretic approach seeks to characterizes the meaning of a sentence in terms of what it is to prove it or, say, to recognize it, in contrast with the truth-theoretic approach drawn upon a recognition-transcendent notion of truth.We argue that the transmission view of consequence, encapsulated in the standard proof-theoretic approach, flaws the possibility of developing a real alternative to a truth-based approach. The research aims at the development of an alternative proof-theoretic approach, based on the rejection of the 'transmission' view of consequence, capable of yielding a conception of meaning anchored to subjects' epistemological capabilities.Keywords: Logical Consequence, Proof-Theoretic Semantics, Theory of Meaning
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Falsity and refutations: Understanding the negative side of logic
-
批准号:397512418
-
项目类别:Research Grants
-
资助金额:$0.0万
-
财政年份:2018
-
负责人:Dr. Luca Tranchini
-
依托单位:
Logical consequence and paradoxical reasoning
-
批准号:289086941
-
项目类别:Research Grants
-
资助金额:$0.0万
-
财政年份:2015
-
负责人:Dr. Luca Tranchini
-
依托单位:
海外基金