课题基金 / 基金详情

The responsibility of judges to assure due process: Tension among neutrality, rights protection, and role

The responsibility of judges to assure due process: Tension among neutrality, rights protection, and role
法官确保正当程序的责任:中立性、权利保护和角色之间的紧张关系
批准号:
1456772
负责人:
Larry Heuer
金额:
$19.38万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2015
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2015-07-01 至 2017-06-30

项目摘要

项目成果

Larry Heuer的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
摘要:法官确保正当程序的责任:中立性、权利保护和角色之间的紧张关系美国最高法院在特纳诉罗杰斯案(2011)中的决定促使人们考虑法官在一方或多方没有律师代表的案件中的作用。在特纳案中,最高法院认为,审理子女抚养案件的法官负有确保司法程序对没有律师代理的父母是公平的具体责任。特纳引发了一场辩论,即法官如何履行义务,确保司法程序对没有律师的当事人是公平的,同时履行对所有当事人中立适用法律的义务。这个问题很流行。在全国各地的社区,州法院挤满了数以百万计的人,他们负担不起私人律师的费用,也无法获得民事法律援助协会提供的有限的免费服务。因此,社区正在权衡一系列选择,以帮助确保没有律师的人公平解决案件。许多州修改了各自的司法行为准则,或为法官制定了其他指导方针,规定法官可以采取措施,确保司法程序对无律师代表的当事人是公平的,同时又不违反法官对所有当事人中立适用法律的义务。然而,如何在实地实现这些变化是一个复杂的问题。本项目进行的两项研究将审查法官是否以及如何履行其确保司法程序对无代表当事方公平的职责,同时履行其确保法律中立地适用于所有当事方的职责这一问题的不同方面。研究成果将对程序正义理论的发展和司法教育的实践与政策提供参考。该项目还具有更广泛的教育影响,包括对本科生、法律系学生和博士后的培训和指导。这两项研究都将在纽约市住房法院进行,特别侧重于住房法院法官在审查拟议的和解规定的公正性方面的作用,在这些案件中,房东以房客据称未支付租金为理由,向无律师代表的房客提起诉讼,要求收回公寓。第一项研究——一个法庭实验——询问培训法官在涉及无代表当事人的案件中维护程序公平是否可以a)增加与无代表当事人的司法参与,b)帮助无代表当事人了解案件所需的信息,和/或c)增加无代表当事人对程序公平和法院合法性的看法。该实验将对40名法官进行程序公平方面的培训,并对法官(及其案件中的诉讼人和律师)进行培训前和培训后的五次审判调查(从而允许对培训效果进行控制测试)。将观察400个目标案例,并对参与者的行为和结果进行系统编码(考虑到上述因变量)。一组训练有素的法律专业学生将对案件档案进行编码。第二项研究是一项对照实验,它问的是,对所有各方进行教育,让他们了解法官在维护无代表政党的程序公平方面的作用,是否可以最大限度地减少各方对法官偏袒无代表政党的可能看法。实验涉及3(当事人代表平衡:平衡,任何一方代表与不平衡,租户代表与不平衡,房东代表)x2(法官根据培训参与vs被动)x2(当事人:租户vs房东)x2(结果:有利于房东vs有利于租户)x2(程序概述:出席vs缺席)。预计这两项研究将阐明其他基本问题,包括以下问题:a)无代表当事人对其应得待遇的看法是否会影响他们对司法程序是否公平的看法? b)程序公平对当事人和法官是否同样重要?
英文摘要
AbstractSES-1456772The Responsibility of Judges to Assure Due Process: Tension Among Neutrality, Rights Protection, and RolePI - Larry HeuerCo-PI - Steven PenrodThe decision of the US Supreme Court in Turner v. Rogers (2011) has prompted consideration of the role of judges in cases in which a party, or parties, are not represented by counsel. In Turner, the Court held that judges in child support cases have a specific duty to ensure that judicial processes are fair to parents who are not represented by counsel. Turner has given rise to debate about how judges can fulfill the duty to ensure that judicial processes are fair to parties without counsel while at the same fulfilling the duty to apply the law neutrally to all parties. The question has considerable currency. In communities across the country, state courts are inundated by millions of people unable to afford private counsel and unable to secure the limited free services made available by the civil legal aid bar. Communities are therefore weighing a range of options to helping to assure the fair resolution of cases for people without lawyers. Many states have modified their respective codes of judicial conduct, or have developed other guidance for judges, to provide that a judge may take steps to ensure that judicial processes are fair to unrepresented parties without violating the judge's duty to apply the law neutrally to all parties. Yet, how these changes will be realized on the ground is a complicated matter. Two studies carried out by this project will examine different aspects of the question of whether and how judges can fulfill their duty to ensure that judicial processes are fair to unrepresented parties while at the same fulfilling their duty to ensure that the law is applied neutrally to all parties. The research findings are expected to advance theory on procedural justice and inform practice and policy on judicial education. The project also has a broader educational impact, including training and mentoring of undergraduate students, law students, and a postdoctoral fellow. Both studies will be carried out in the New York City Housing Court, specifically focusing on the role of Housing Court Judges in reviewing the fairness of proposed stipulations of settlement in cases in which a landlord has brought an action seeking recovery of an apartment from an unrepresented tenant based on the tenant's alleged nonpayment of rent. The first study--a courtroom experiment--asks whether training judges to preserve procedural fairness in cases involving unrepresented parties can a) increase judicial engagement with the unrepresented party, b) help the unrepresented party understand the information needed in the case, and/or c) increase the unrepresented party's perception of procedural fairness and of the legitimacy of the court. The experiment will train 40 judges in procedural fairness and survey the judges (and litigants and attorneys in their cases) on five trials prior to the judges' training and five trials after training (thus permitting controlled testing of training effects). Four hundred target cases will be observed and the behaviors of the participants and outcomes systematically coded (with the above dependent variables in mind). A team of trained law students will code the case files. The second study--a controlled experiment--asks whether educating all the parties about the role of judges in preserving procedural fairness for unrepresented parties can minimize the parties' possible perception of judges as biased in favor of unrepresented parties. The experiment involves a 3 (Party Representation Balance: Balanced, Neither party represented vs. Imbalanced, tenant represented vs. Imbalanced, landlord represented) x 2 (Judge is engaged as per training vs. passive) x 2 (Party: Tenant vs. Landlord) x 2 (Outcome: Favors landlord vs. favors tenant) x 2 (Procedure Overview: Present vs. absent). The two studies are expected to cast light on additional underlying questions, including the following: a) do unrepresented parties' views on the treatment they deserve have a bearing on their perceptions of whether the judicial processes are fair, and b) is procedural fairness as important to the parties as it is to the judges?
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
RUI: An Investigation of a Decision Maker-decision Recipient Disparity in the Meaning and Importance of Procedural Justice
  • 批准号:
    0550495
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $19.11万
  • 财政年份:
    2006
  • 负责人:
    Larry Heuer
  • 依托单位:
RUI: Three Challenges to Procedural Justice Theory: Studying the View of the Boss, the Beat, and the Bench
  • 批准号:
    9710946
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $10.74万
  • 财政年份:
    1997
  • 负责人:
    Larry Heuer
  • 依托单位:
RUI: Group Value Versus Self Interest Concern in Fairness Judgements: A Test of a Contextual Priming Model
  • 批准号:
    9224566
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $7.42万
  • 财政年份:
    1993
  • 负责人:
    Larry Heuer
  • 依托单位:
海外基金