The Role Of Markets In The Development Of Social Complexity

市场在社会复杂性发展中的作用

• 批准号: 1623758
• 负责人: Leah Minc
• 金额: $ 17.98万
• 依托单位: Oregon State University
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 项目类别: Standard Grant
• 财政年份: 2016
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2016-07-01 至 2019-12-31
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1623758&HistoricalAwards=false
• 关键词: Role; Markets; Development; Social; Complexity

Dr. Leah Minc, of Oregon State University, and an international team of collaborators will explore the origins of market-place exchange and the specific political and social conditions fostering market systems in ancient economies. Although markets are a fundamental part of modern economy, scholars question whether similar commercial exchange systems developed in ancient societies and debate which factors stimulated their emergence and growth in non-western economic traditions. From the perspective of modern microeconomic theory, some researchers have argued that commercial exchange and a complex division of labor evolved naturally in complex societies as an efficient solution to provisioning large populations with essential goods, once political stability ensured freedom of movement and rule of law. Other scholars, in contrast, dispute the applicability of the modern mind-set (including assumptions of economic rationality, competition, and profit motive) to non-western or pre-industrial societies. For example, some historians question whether in highly stratified societies, where control over the means of production (land and labor) was firmly held by the ruling class, production and exchange built on profit incentives could reasonably develop among the peasantry, or whether in these cases alternative forms of exchange (such as extended family networks) might provide a means for acquiring needed commodities. Archaeology is well poised to evaluate the universality of micro-economic assumptions, by examining the evidence for market exchange in the distant past, as well as the political and social context for its development and the possible persistence of alternative forms of exchange that supplied communities with necessary materials. This collaborative project will examine a pristine case of market system development by using nuclear science and geochemical techniques to trace exchanges of basic, utilitarian goods. The project will focus on the Valley of Oaxaca, Mexico, home to one of the best documented early state societies in the New World, and will explore how key political events affected regional economic interaction and integration through time. Drawing on excavated collections of domestic pottery from communities throughout the valley, the research team will use robust methods of trace-element analysis (instrumental neutron activation analysis) to establish where ceramic vessels were manufactured, map their movement from producer to consumer, and assess the spatial scale, organization, and intensity of intra-valley exchange across key periods of state emergence and consolidation (from ca. 700 BC through 550 AD). The observed distribution patterns will provide a sound foundation from which to re-assess specific models of market system evolution, as well as a means for future studies to address how these economic changes affected households' production, consumption, and exchange decisions. Further, the intersection of archaeology and nuclear science will create opportunities for STEM education and professional training for students in the social sciences; at the same time, due to its "human appeal," archaeometric research can build support for nuclear science, engaging public interest and justifying infrastructure and lab equipment upgrades.

俄勒冈州立大学的 Leah Minc 博士和一个国际合作者团队将探讨市场交换的起源以及古代经济体中培育市场体系的具体政治和社会条件。尽管市场是现代经济的基本组成部分，但学者们质疑古代社会是否发展了类似的商业交换体系，并争论哪些因素刺激了它们在非西方经济传统中的出现和发展。 从现代微观经济理论的角度来看，一些研究人员认为，一旦政治稳定确保了迁徙自由和法治，商业交换和复杂的劳动分工就会在复杂的社会中自然演变，成为为大量人口提供必需品的有效解决方案。相比之下，其他学者则质疑现代思维模式（包括经济理性、竞争和利润动机的假设）对非西方或前工业社会的适用性。 例如，一些历史学家质疑，在高度分层的社会中，统治阶级牢牢控制着生产资料（土地和劳动力），建立在利润激励之上的生产和交换是否可以在农民中合理发展，或者在这些情况下，替代形式的交换（例如大家庭网络）是否可以提供获取所需商品的手段。 考古学可以通过研究遥远过去市场交换的证据、其发展的政治和社会背景以及为社区提供必要材料的替代交换形式的可能持续性来评估微观经济假设的普遍性。 该合作项目将通过利用核科学和地球化学技术来追踪基本的实用商品的交换，研究市场体系发展的原始案例。 该项目将重点关注墨西哥瓦哈卡谷，这里是新大陆记录最齐全的早期国家社会之一，并将探讨关键的政治事件如何影响区域经济互动和一体化。 研究小组将利用从整个山谷社区出土的国内陶器收藏品，使用强大的微量元素分析方法（仪器中子活化分析）来确定陶瓷器皿的制造地点，绘制陶瓷器皿从生产者到消费者的移动轨迹，并评估国家出现和巩固的关键时期（约公元前 700 年至公元 550 年）山谷内交换的空间规模、组织和强度。 观察到的分配模式将为重新评估市场体系演变的具体模型提供坚实的基础，并为未来研究解决这些经济变化如何影响家庭的生产、消费和交换决策提供手段。 此外，考古学和核科学的交叉将为社会科学学生的 STEM 教育和专业培训创造机会；与此同时，由于其“人类吸引力”，考古研究可以为核科学提供支持，吸引公众兴趣并证明基础设施和实验室设备升级的合理性。