Implementation and compliance with human rights law: An exploration of the interplay between the international, regional and national levels

人权法的实施和遵守：探索国际、区域和国家层面之间的相互作用

• 批准号: ES/M008819/1
• 负责人: Rachel Murray
• 金额: $ 140.16万
• 依托单位: University of Bristol
• 依托单位国家: 英国
• 项目类别: Research Grant
• 财政年份: 2015
• 资助国家: 英国
• 起止时间: 2015 至 无数据
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=ES%2FM008819%2F1
• 关键词: Implementation; compliance; human; rights; law

An 'implementation crisis' is widely acknowledged to be afflicting regional and international human rights mechanisms, including the European Convention system which historically enjoyed relatively high levels of compliance. This situation adds urgency to a debate which is long-established but remains unresolved: what does it mean to comply with international and regional human rights law and what factors influence whether states comply or not? Moving beyond existing literature and research, this much-needed and innovative study will examine the factors which impact on the implementation by nine states (Colombia, Guatemala, Canada; Georgia, Czech Republic, Finland; Cameroon, Algeria and Tanzania) of (i) selected decisions deriving from individual complaints to UN treaty bodies; and (ii) selected judgments and decisions of the bodies in the three regional human rights systems (Europe, Americas and Africa).This is a collaborative effort between the four leading academic human rights centres (Bristol, Essex, Middlesex and Pretoria) and the Open Society Justice Initiative. The PI, Co-Is and partner organisation bring individually and collectively unrivalled expertise, contacts and experience in implementation of human rights law. As practitioners they have litigated before these regional and UN bodies, organised influential seminars and other events and provide advice on implementation of decisions and judgments. As academics they have written extensively in the field. The Open Society Justice Initiative (OSJI) has an enviable range of contacts across the three regions and at the UN and is considered one of the key civil society players in the human rights field. Together with Bristol coordinating the project and providing African expertise with Pretoria, Middlesex's European Human Rights Advocacy Centre inputting the European expertise and Essex's Human Rights Centre offering the Inter-American contribution, the project team are extremely well placed to combine the academic and practitioner background necessary to carry out this innovative and ambitious research. Through semi-structured interviews, participant observation, workshops and a range of published outputs directed at policy and academic audiences, this research it will attempt to get to the heart of the utility and relevance of human rights law in the 21st century, an issue which is concern to state actors (governments, legislatures and judiciaries); civil society actors; human rights bodies; and victims (and potential) victims of human rights violations. The research also hopes to be able to impact on the actual compliance by the states with selected decisions and thereby resulting in greater justice for the individual victims.

人们普遍认为，“执行危机”正在影响区域和国际人权机制，包括历史上遵守率相对较高的欧洲公约体系。这种情况使一个由来已久但仍未解决的辩论更加紧迫：遵守国际和区域人权法意味着什么，哪些因素影响各国是否遵守？超越现有的文献和研究，这项急需的创新研究将审查影响九个州实施的因素（哥伦比亚、危地马拉、加拿大;格鲁吉亚、捷克共和国、芬兰;喀麦隆、阿尔及利亚和坦桑尼亚）（一）联合国条约机构收到的个人申诉所产生的若干决定;以及（ii）三个区域人权系统机构的部分判决和决定（欧洲、美洲和非洲）。这是四个主要学术人权中心之间的合作努力（布里斯托、埃塞克斯、米德尔塞克斯和比勒陀利亚）和开放社会司法倡议。PI、Co-Is和合作伙伴组织在实施人权法方面带来了个人和集体无与伦比的专业知识、联系和经验。作为从业人员，他们在这些区域和联合国机构提起诉讼，组织有影响力的研讨会和其他活动，并就执行决定和判决提供咨询意见。作为学者，他们在这个领域写了大量的文章。开放社会正义倡议在三个区域和联合国拥有令人羡慕的广泛联系，被认为是人权领域的主要民间社会参与者之一。布里斯托负责协调该项目，并与比勒陀利亚、米德尔塞克斯的欧洲人权宣传中心和埃塞克斯的人权中心一起提供非洲的专门知识，项目小组非常有条件将开展这项创新和雄心勃勃的研究所需的学术和实践背景联合收割机结合起来。通过半结构化访谈、参与者观察、研讨会和一系列针对政策和学术受众的出版物，这项研究将试图触及21世纪人权法的实用性和相关性的核心，这是国家行为者关注的问题。（政府、立法机构和司法机构）;民间社会行为者;人权机构;以及侵犯人权行为的受害者（和潜在的）受害者。这项研究还希望能够影响各州对选定决定的实际遵守情况，从而为受害者个人带来更大的正义。

项目成果

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights and Implementation of Recommendations in Individual Cases

美洲人权和个案建议落实委员会

• DOI: 10.1093/jhuman/huaa010
• 发表时间: 2020
• 期刊: Journal of Human Rights Practice
• 影响因子: 1
• 作者: Abi-Mershed E

Implementing Human Rights Decisions: Reflections, Successes, and New Directions. Introduction to the Series. Blog posts on Implementing Human Rights Decisions: Reflections, Successes, and New Directions

实施人权决策：反思、成功和新方向。

• 发表时间: 2021
• 作者: De Vos C

Implementation of judgments: practical insights from non-state actors

判决的执行：非国家行为者的实际见解

• 发表时间: 2020
• 期刊: Journal of Human Rights Practice
• 影响因子: 1
• 作者: Dailey E

Doctrine, Practice and Advocacy in the Inter-American Human Rights System

美洲人权体系的理论、实践和倡导

• 发表时间: 2019
• 作者: Bettinger-Lopez C

Research Handbook on Compliance in International Human Rights Law

国际人权法合规研究手册

• 发表时间: 2020
• 作者: Donald