课题基金 / 基金详情

The Communicative Mind

The Communicative Mind
沟通的心灵
批准号:
MR/S033858/1
负责人:
Richard Moore
金额:
$97.55万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Fellowship
财政年份:
2020
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
未结题
起止时间:
2020 至 --
关键词:

项目摘要

项目成果

Richard Moore的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
为什么人类而非猿类能够获得语言?根据一个标准的观点(Tomasello 2008; Scott-Phillips 2014),只有人类才能获得语言,因为我们拥有对心理理论(“ToM”)的生物适应性-思考他人心理状态的能力-大猩猩缺乏。这些使我们能够与自然语言发展所必需的“Grice”(Grice 1957)交际意图一起行动并归因于它。由于类人猿缺乏ToM,它们既不能归因于交际意图,也不能习得语言。对于标准观点来说,格赖斯式交流所需的心理理论似乎只有在孩子们四岁左右掌握了某些自然语言形式--“实在补语从句”句法--之后才能发展起来。如果格赖斯沟通所需的读心术本身是依赖于语言的,那么它不能有助于解释儿童的语言习得。由于新的经验数据(Krupenye & Kano,2017)也表明类人猿的心理理论与语言前婴儿的心理理论相似,标准观点无法解释类人猿语言的缺失。为了解决这些解释性难题,沟通思维项目将对心理理论、语言和沟通之间的关系进行新的解释。PI以前的工作表明,婴儿和猿都可以参与社会认知要求不高的“最低限度Gricean”交流形式,该项目将建立人类和猿之间的关键社会认知差异是文化学习,而不是生物遗传。它们的出现是因为人类而非猿类可以使用句法结构化的话语进行交流,也因为在这种能力的基础上,一代又一代的语言使用者开发了语言工具来理论化心理状态。因此,不是心理理论解释了语言的发展,而是语言的句法和文化演变解释了心理理论的发展。儿童通过对话和讲故事的文化实践,在个体发育中学习使用这些工具,从而获得思考心灵的新工具。《沟通心智》将对语言在个体发育中的进化和心理理论在个体发育中的发展提出新的解释。在项目的第一年和第二年,PI(哲学家)将与发展心理学家合作,进行一系列开创性的研究,以阐明补充子句语法掌握和代表他人所知的能力之间的发展关系。通过首次使用言语和非言语范式来研究儿童掌握嵌入式、层次结构的补充分句形式的发展,我们将产生支持儿童读心和语言发展的认知机制的新知识。在项目的第3年和第4年,PI将与语言学家合作,为人类历史上补充子句语法的出现提供新的见解。我们将对人类认知结构的系统发生进行新的解释,这种认知结构允许我们使用句法结构化的语言,但不允许我们的类人猿堂兄弟使用。随后,我们将使用现有的语言的比较,以开发一个帐户的文化演变的补充条款,如句法在自然语言。这些分项目将联合收割机结合起来,说明使用语言表达他人对世界的看法的能力的文化根源。我们将展示如何通过交际互动的过程来创建和学习心理理论的语言工具,并描述它们赋予说话者的新的表征工具。通过展示人类独特的认知特征是通过交流产生的,我们将展示人类思想的根本社会基础。随后,我们将利用我们的研究结果开发教育工具,以支持儿童的学习。
英文摘要
Why do humans but not apes acquire language?According to a standard view (Tomasello 2008; Scott-Phillips 2014) humans alone acquire language because we possess biological adaptations for Theory of Mind ('ToM') - the ability to think about others' mental states - that great apes lack. These enable us to act with and attribute the 'Gricean' (Grice 1957) communicative intentions that are necessary for natural language development. Since great apes lack ToM, they can neither attribute communicative intentions nor acquire language. Problematically for the standard view, the ToM needed for Gricean communication seem to develop only with the mastery of certain natural language forms - 'realis complement clause' syntax - around children's fourth birthday. If the mindreading needed for Gricean communication is itself language dependent, then it cannot contribute to an explanation of children's language acquisition. Since new empirical data (Krupenye & Kano, 2017) also shows that the ToM of great apes is similar to that of pre-verbal infants, the standard view leaves the absence of language in great apes unexplained.To dissolve these explanatory puzzles, the Communicative Mind project will develop a new account of the relationship between ToM, language, and communication. Building on the PI's previous work, which shows that infants and apes alike can engage in socio-cognitively undemanding forms of 'minimally Gricean' communication, the project will establish that key socio-cognitive differences between humans and apes are culturally learned, not biologically inherited. They emerge because humans but not apes can use syntactically structured utterances to communicate, and because on the back of this ability generations of language-users have developed linguistic tools for theorising about mental states. Thus, it is not ToM that explains the development of language, but syntax and the cultural evolution of language that explains the development of ToM. Children learn to use these tools in ontogeny, through cultural practices of conversation and storytelling, and thereby acquire new tools for thinking about minds. The Communicative Mind will develop new accounts of the evolution of language in phylogeny, and of the development of ToM in ontogeny. In years 1 and 2 of the project, the PI (a philosopher) will work with a developmental psychologist to conduct a series of pioneering studies to illuminate the developmental relationship between complement clause syntax mastery and the ability to represent what others know. By using, for the first time, both verbal and non-verbal paradigms to study the development of children's mastery of embedded, hierarchically structured complement clause forms, we will generate new knowledge of the cognitive mechanisms that support the development of children's mindreading and language. In years 3 and 4 of the project, the PI will work with a linguist to shed new light on the emergence of complement clause syntax in human history. We will develop a new account of the phylogenetic emergence in humans of a cognitive architecture that allows us, but not our great ape cousins, to use syntactically structured language. Subsequently we will use comparisons of existing languages to develop an account of the cultural evolution of complement-clause like syntax in natural languages. These subprojects will combine to give an account of the cultural origins of the ability to use language to represent others' perspectives on the world. We will show how linguistic tools for ToM can be created and learned through processes of communicative interaction, and describe the new representational tools with which they imbue speakers. By showing that uniquely human cognitive traits emerge through communication, we will demonstrate the fundamentally social foundations of human thought. Subsequently we will use our findings to develop educational tools to support children's learning.
期刊论文(10)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Toddlers Prefer Adults as Informants: 2- and 3-Year-Olds' Use of and Attention to Pointing Gestures From Peer and Adult Partners
幼儿更喜欢成人作为线人:2 岁和 3 岁的孩子使用并注意同伴和成人伙伴的指向手势
DOI: 10.1111/cdev.13544
发表时间: 2021
期刊: Child Development
影响因子: 4.6
作者: [Kachel G]
通讯作者: Kachel G
The cultural evolution of mind-modelling
心智建模的文化演变
DOI: 10.1007/s11229-020-02853-3
发表时间: 2020
期刊: Synthese
影响因子: 1.5
作者: [Moore R]
通讯作者: Moore R
DOI: 10.1007/s11229-023-04300-5
发表时间: 2023-08-24
期刊: SYNTHESE
影响因子: 1.5
作者: [Hildebrandt,Frauke, Glauer,Ramiro, Moore,Richard]
通讯作者: Moore,Richard
DOI: 10.1017/s0140525x23000717
发表时间: 2023
期刊: Behavioral and Brain Sciences
影响因子: 29.3
作者: [Berio L]
通讯作者: Berio L
共 10 条
    The Communicative Mind
    • 批准号:
      MR/Y011678/1
    • 项目类别:
      Fellowship
    • 资助金额:
      $75.9万
    • 财政年份:
      2024
    • 负责人:
      Richard Moore
    • 依托单位:
    Collaborative Research: Mathematical and computational methods for stochastic systems in nonlinear optics
    • 批准号:
      1109278
    • 项目类别:
      Standard Grant
    • 资助金额:
      $15.1万
    • 财政年份:
      2011
    • 负责人:
      Richard Moore
    • 依托单位:
    Linking Watershed Research and GK-12 Education within an Ecosystem Context
    Blue Ribbon Panel on Sustainable Digital Preservation and Access
    • 批准号:
      0737721
    • 项目类别:
      Continuing Grant
    • 资助金额:
      $0.0万
    • 财政年份:
      2007
    • 负责人:
      Richard Moore
    • 依托单位:
    国内基金
    海外基金
    噬菌体PaP3基因产物Gp68上调铜绿假单胞菌minD/mvaT基因发挥抗菌作用的机制和应用研究
    木薯ftsZ和minD基因在淀粉体分裂和淀粉品质改良中的作用
    • 批准号:
      31160061
    • 项目类别:
      地区科学基金项目
    • 资助金额:
      49.0万元
    • 批准年份:
      2011
    • 负责人:
      闵义
    • 依托单位: