Seismic Justice: The Ethics & Politics of Megathrust Earthquake Risk Management
Seismic Justice: The Ethics & Politics of Megathrust Earthquake Risk Management
批准号:
2445389
负责人:
金额:
$0.0万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Studentship
财政年份:
2020
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
未结题
起止时间:
2020 至 --
中文摘要
科学、伦理和公共政策分析如何协同工作,以减轻特大地震的风险?我的博士研究通过深入调查北美太平洋西北部地区(同义词为卡斯卡迪亚)大地震和伴随而来的海啸的危险来探索这个问题。地质证据表明,从加利福尼亚州北部到不列颠哥伦比亚省的这一700英里长的地区,在过去10,000年里发生了41次8.0级以上的地震,其中包括19次9.0级以上的地震(Schulz 2015)。上一次袭击太平洋西北部的大地震发生在1700年1月26日(阿特沃特等人)。2005年;Jacoby等人。1997年;Satake et al.1996年;Yamaguchi et al.最近的灾难,如2004年的印度洋地震和2011年的东北地震,证明了巨型断裂带地震及其伴随的海啸的破坏性。数以百万计的人面临着卡斯卡迪亚地区发生类似灾难的可能性,但地震何时发生、震级有多大以及后果的严重性仍不确定。卡斯卡迪亚大地震不太可能在任何一年发生,但一旦发生肯定会造成大范围的破坏,对这种风险的理性反应是什么(Zack 2006:12)?我的论文以卡斯卡迪亚为例,研究其在美国和加拿大应急计划中的政策重要性。因此,我的中心研究问题是:在卡斯卡迪亚,什么伦理框架应该指导巨型地震和海啸风险管理准备政策的制定?为了回答这个问题,我将回答以下几个子问题:(1)哪些伦理原则应该指导足够的保护水平和公平的保护分配?(2)如果防震政策有赢家和输家,收益和负担应该如何分配?(3)作为代际风险的情况,需要采取什么个人政策应对卡斯卡迪亚大地震的威胁,当代和未来几代人都会受到影响?(4)应该如何设计机构来考虑卡斯卡迪亚大地震的威胁所产生的代际风险?(5)鉴于卡斯卡迪亚地震风险是一个跨国界的问题,在涉及美国和加拿大的情况下,应如何在国际、国家和国家以下各级分配责任?相关的经验文献来自政策制定者和政策顾问(OSSPAC,2013年)、灾害专家(如Tierney,2019)和风险学者(Bailey,2011年)。然而,所有这些都没有明确地植根于伦理原则。此外,还有关于社会正义、风险(Frick 2015;Horton 2017;Tadros 2013)和代际责任(评论见Caney 2018;Meyer 2020)的复杂哲学讨论。与此同时,灾难伦理本身在哲学文献中仍然处于边缘地位(现有著作包括扎克2009年;Doorn 2015;Brake 2019)。这些哲学讨论都没有实质性地提到地震风险管理,也没有系统地处理相关的规范性原则。因此,我对学术文献的主要贡献是为卡斯卡迪亚发展了一套系统的地震风险管理规范理论,一方面将对地震和现有地震政策的经验理解与哲学分析结合在一起。作为我的分析策略的一部分,我的目标是对精英和社区利益相关者进行定性的半结构化(虚拟)访谈,以阐明进行规范分析所需的相关经验背景。出于不同的原因,将招募不同的参与者群体。
英文摘要
How can science, ethics and public policy analysis work together to mitigate the risk of very large earthquakes? My PhD research explores this question through an in-depth investigation of the hazards from megathrust earthquakes and accompanying tsunamis in the Pacific Northwest area of North America (known synonymously as Cascadia). Geological evidence indicates that this 700-mile region, stretching from northern California to British Columbia, has seen 41 earthquakes greater than magnitude 8.0 in the past 10,000 years, including 19 greater than magnitude 9.0 (Schulz 2015). The last great quake to hit the Pacific Northwest occurred on January 26, 1700 (Atwater et al. 2005; Jacoby et al. 1997; Satake et al. 1996; Yamaguchi et al. 1997).Recent disasters, such as the Indian Ocean earthquake of 2004 and the Tohoku quake of 2011, have exemplified the destructiveness of megathrust earthquakes and their accompanying tsunamis. Millions of people face the possibility of a similar catastrophe in the Cascadia region, but uncertainty remains over when the quake will occur, how large it will be and the severity of the consequences. What is the rational response to the risk of a major Cascadia earthquake, which is unlikely to materialize in any given year but is certain to cause widespread disruption when it does (Zack 2006: 12)? My thesis examines Cascadia as a case study for its policy import in the contexts of both American and Canadian emergency planning.Therefore, my central research question is: "What ethical framework should guide the development of preparedness policy for megathrust earthquake and tsunami risk management in Cascadia?" To answer this, I will address several sub-questions, as follows:(1) Which ethical principles should guide an adequate level of protection and the fair distribution of protection?(2) If there are winners and losers from earthquake preparedness policy, how should the benefits and burdens be distributed?(3) What individual policy responses are required to deal with the threat of large Cascadia earthquakes as a case of intergenerational risk, where both current and future generations are affected?(4) How should institutions be designed to account for the intergenerational risk emanating from the threat of large Cascadia earthquakes?(5) Given that Cascadia earthquake risk is a cross-border problem, involving both the United States and Canada, how should responsibilities be distributed among the international, national and sub-national levels?Relevant empirical literatures are drawn from policymakers and policy advisors (OSSPAC 2013), disaster experts (e.g. Tierney 2019) and risk scholars (Bailey 2011). However, none of these are explicitly grounded in ethical principles. Additionally, there are sophisticated philosophical discussions of social justice, risk (Frick 2015; Horton 2017; Tadros 2013) and intergenerational responsibilities (for reviews, see Caney 2018; Meyer 2020). Meanwhile disaster ethics itself remains marginal in the philosophical literature (existing work includes Zack 2009; Doorn 2015; Brake 2019). None of these philosophical discussions substantively invoke earthquake risk management, nor do they provide a systematic treatment of the relevant normative principles. Thus my central contribution to the scholarly literature is to develop a systematic normative theory of earthquake risk management for Cascadia, one which integrates an empirical understanding of earthquakes and existing seismic policy, on the one hand, with philosophical analysis, on the other.As part of my analytical strategy, I aim to conduct qualitative semi-structured (virtual) interviews with both elites and community stakeholders in order to elucidate the relevant empirical background necessary for conducting the normative analysis. Different groups of participants will be recruited for different reasons.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
海外基金