Addressing Individual Provider Bias and Group Decision-Making in Selection of Advanced Heart Failure Therapies in Racial/Ethnic Minorities

解决少数种族/族裔高级心力衰竭治疗选择中的个体提供者偏见和群体决策

• 批准号: 9755243
• 负责人: Khadijah Breathett
• 金额: $ 17.5万
• 依托单位: UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 财政年份: 2018
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2018-08-15 至 2023-06-30
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://reporter.nih.gov/project-details/9755243
• 关键词: Address; Area; Child; Clinical; Consensus; Data; Decision Making; Diagnosis; Education; Eligibility Determination; Ethnic Origin; Evaluation; Expert Opinion; Fibrinogen; Funding; Guidelines; Health Personnel; Health Professional; Healthcare; Healthcare Systems; Heart Transplantation; Heart failure; Individual; Institute of Medicine (U.S.); Interview; Knowledge; Life; Literature; Measurement; Measures; Medical Care Team; Medicine; Mentorship; Methods; Minority; Nature; Organ; Outcome; Patient Selection; Patients; Play; Population; Population Heterogeneity; Positioning Attribute; Process; Protocols documentation; Provider; Race; Reporting; Research; Research Training; Role; Schools; Selection for Treatments; Social Psychology; Social support; Standardization; Structure; Surveys; System; Testing; Thinking; Time; Transplantation; Treatment Failure; United States; Visual; analog; aortic valve replacement; base; candidate selection; career; career development; computerized data processing; ethnic bias; ethnic minority population; health care disparity; health equity; implementation science; implicit bias; innovation; left ventricular assist device; medication compliance; meetings; multidisciplinary; patient population; pragmatic trial; programs; racial and ethnic; racial minority

ABSTRACT Bias is present in multiple facets of life and influences decision-making particularly among racial/ethnic minorities. Bias also likely plays a strong role in the process of selecting candidates for advanced heart failure therapies, including heart transplants and left ventricular assist devices, because of the subjective nature of the process. Implicit bias has been well studied in medicine but has not been found to be universally instrumental in changing outcomes, and healthcare group decision-making has not been well studied. Therefore, the application of mixed-methods to study individual healthcare provider bias and group decision-making is innovative. For the first time, the think aloud protocol, a method of elucidating decision-making thoughts for thematic qualitative analysis, and a visual analog scale survey will be used to assess individual provider bias, and the de Groot Critically Reflective Diagnosis protocol, a methodical quantification of reflective group decision-making, will be used to assess the group decision-making process for selection of candidates for advanced therapy for heart failure. We will identify the single most important subjective factor that contributes to racial/ethnic bias and lower reflective scores. An objective measurement of this factor will be used in a standardized protocol for evaluating patients for advanced therapies. Naturalistic evaluation of implementation of this protocol will lead to protocol tailoring that will provide groundwork for a pragmatic R01 trial. The findings of this study will also have implications for other populations that use multidisciplinary healthcare providers for decision-making such as selection of patients for transcatheter aortic valve replacement and transplantation of other organs.

摘要 偏见存在于生活的多个方面，并影响决策，特别是在种族/族裔之间 少数群体在选择晚期心力衰竭候选人的过程中，偏倚也可能发挥重要作用 治疗，包括心脏移植和左心室辅助装置，因为主观性质的 过程内隐偏见在医学上已经得到了很好的研究，但还没有被发现是普遍的工具 在改变结果，医疗保健群体决策尚未得到很好的研究。因此 应用混合方法研究个体医疗服务提供者的偏见和群体决策， 新颖啊这是第一次，大声思考协议，一种阐明决策思想的方法， 专题定性分析和视觉模拟量表调查将用于评估个别供应商的偏见， 和de Groot批判性反思诊断协议，一种对反思组进行系统量化的方法， 决策，将用于评估选择候选人的群体决策过程， 治疗心力衰竭的先进疗法我们将确定造成影响的最重要的主观因素 种族/民族偏见和较低的反思分数。对这一因素的客观衡量将用于 用于评估患者接受先进治疗的标准化方案。执行情况的自然评价 该方案的实施将导致方案的定制，为实用的R 01试验提供基础。这些发现 这项研究的结果也将对其他使用多学科医疗保健提供者的人群产生影响， 决策，如选择患者进行经导管主动脉瓣置换术和移植， 其他器官。