Robust estimates of the prevalence of drinking-and-driving using secondary data

使用二手数据对酒后驾驶发生率进行稳健估计

• 批准号: 10830694
• 负责人: Lauren Jones
• 金额: $ 19.31万
• 依托单位: OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 财政年份: 2022
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2022-09-13 至 2024-08-31
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://reporter.nih.gov/project-details/10830694
• 关键词: Robust; estimates; prevalence; drinking; driving

Project Summary Researchers and policymakers require reliable estimates of both the prevalence and the relative risk of drinking-and-driving. The optimal allocation of public health and traffic safety resources, the efficient level of enforcement, and the appropriate penalty to criminal offenses depend critically on whether: a) relatively few drivers expose other road-users to extreme risk, or b) relatively many drivers expose other road-users to moderate risk. Existing surveys and statistical methods each impose questionable behavioral assumptions and produce an uninformatively wide range of values. To overcome these challenges, we propose a bias-corrected version of the LPDT method developed by Levitt and Porter (2001) and Dunn and Tefft (2020) (hereafter, bc- LPDT) that relaxes the assumption that the probability of one driver-type interacting with another driver-type depends only on the share of each driver-type on the road. This project builds vital research infrastructure by: 1) augmenting the maximum likelihood function to account for the spatiotemporal sorting of drivers; 2) estimating driver interaction probabilities; and 3) generating unbiased estimates of the prevalence and crash risk associated with drinking-and-driving using existing administrative data. We will apply this method to two data sources: the Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) (Aim 1) and Crash Report Sampling System (CRSS) (Aim 2). FARS is a census of fatal crashes in the US and will allow us to recover the relative risk of alcohol-involved (BAC>0) and alcohol-impaired (BAC≥0.08) drivers causing a fatal crash. CRSS is a nationally representative sample of all motor vehicle crashes, allowing us to recover the relative risk of causing any crash. The accompanying estimates of prevalence will make an immediate contribution by resolving the outstanding question of whether prevalence has fallen steadily over the past four decades (consistent with NRS estimates) or stagnated since the late 1990s (consistent with previous LPDT results and crash statistics). The former would imply the existing policy portfolio continues to show important returns; the latter that existing policy has exhausted its returns and innovation is necessary to reduce the public health cost of drinking and driving. The benefits of demonstrating the feasibility and robustness of this approach, including reconciling estimates across method and dataset (Aim 3) are manifest. First, the bc-LPDT method can be applied to crash data that are published annually, greatly increasing the frequency and timeliness of prevalence and crash risk estimates than is possible with survey instruments. Second, the marginal cost of generating new estimates of prevalence and relative risk from these data is nearly zero. Third, the bc-LPDT method is exceptionally flexible: the approach can be applied to smaller geographies (state-level) and subpopulations (age, gender, race, ethnicity) or characteristics of drivers, vehicles, and crashes to investigate how alcohol involvement interacts with attributes, such as drowsiness, drug involvement, and distraction. Thus, the estimates and methods from this project will be valuable outputs for public health surveillance and inputs for future policy evaluation.

项目摘要 研究人员和政策制定者需要可靠的估计患病率和相对风险。 酒后驾车。优化配置公共卫生和交通安全资源，提高公共卫生和交通安全的效率水平 执法以及对刑事犯罪的适当处罚，关键取决于是否：a)相对较少 司机将其他道路使用者暴露在极端危险中，或b)相对较多的司机将其他道路使用者暴露于 中等风险。现有的调查和统计方法都强加了有问题的行为假设和 产生一个没有信息的广泛的价值范围。为了克服这些挑战，我们提出了一种经过纠正的偏见 由Levitt和Porter(2001)和Dunn和Tefft(2020)开发的LPDT方法的版本(下称BC- LPDT)，这放松了一个驾驶员类型与另一个驾驶员类型相互作用的概率的假设 仅取决于每个驾驶员在道路上的份额。该项目通过以下方式构建重要的研究基础设施： 1)扩展最大似然函数以考虑驱动程序的时空排序；2) 估计驾驶员相互作用的概率；以及3)生成对流行率和撞车的无偏估计 使用现有管理数据与酒后驾车相关的风险。我们将把这种方法应用于两个 数据来源：死亡分析报告系统(AIM 1)和坠机报告抽样系统 (CRSS)(目标2)。FARS是对美国致命撞车事故的普查，它将使我们能够恢复 酒后驾车(BAC&gt；0)和酒后驾车(BAC≥0.08)导致致命车祸。CRSS是一家全国性的 所有机动车撞车事故的代表性样本，使我们能够恢复造成任何 撞车。随附的流行率估计将立即做出贡献，解决 过去40年中流行率是否稳步下降的悬而未决的问题(与 NRS估计)，或自1990年代末以来停滞不前(与以前的LPDT结果和坠机统计数据一致)。 前者将意味着现有的政策组合继续显示出重要的回报；后者将意味着现有的 政策已经耗尽了回报，创新是必要的，以降低饮酒和消费的公共健康成本 开车。证明这一方法的可行性和稳健性的好处，包括协调 跨方法和数据集(目标3)的估计是显而易见的。首先，BC-LPDT方法可以应用于CRASH 每年发布的数据，大大提高了流行率和撞车风险的频率和及时性 估计比使用调查工具所能做的要多。第二，产生新的估计的边际成本 这些数据的患病率和相对风险几乎为零。第三，BC-LPDT方法非常灵活： 该方法可以应用于较小的地理区域(州一级)和子群体(年龄、性别、种族、 种族)或司机、车辆和撞车事故的特征，以调查酒精参与如何相互作用 有嗜睡、吸毒和分心等特征。因此，估计和方法来自 该项目将是公共卫生监测的宝贵产出，也是未来政策评估的投入。