Adaptationist Explanations in Biology: A Case Study
Adaptationist Explanations in Biology: A Case Study
批准号:
8708295
负责人:
Elisabeth Lloyd
金额:
$3.0万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
1987
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
1987-07-15 至 1988-12-31
中文摘要
科学是一种社会现象,也就是说,科学是由男女共同完成的, 在科学和社会承诺的前提下来研究他们的课题。 洛依德博士将利用这笔资金研究 对科学理论发展的优先承诺。 她 初步研究显示,它们的影响最能体现在 理论解释与现实之间必然存在的差距, 现有证据。 鉴于经常没有足够的 一个科学家,一个科学家, 这既给问题带来了先前的科学信念, 在这个社会中, 科学的发展是为了一种解释而不是另一种。 一个 这种发展的例子是优生学领域。 科学家 从遗传学中获得了可用的证据,并将其与 种族和文化偏见,在19世纪末, 世纪早期的社会,并制定了一个理论, “净化”和人类的完美。 虽然后果 通常不像优生学那样极端,这些因素 显然在整个过程中或多或少都有影响 科学 劳埃德博士正在研究先前承诺的影响 科学家在发展他们的科学解释, 进化生物学 她在理论上的承诺 这是一种“适应主义”的解释。 “适应性” 故事中的一个特定的特点或财产被认为有 自然选择直接作用的结果是最 突出的进化论解释。 特征本身 被视为适应和解释游戏是提供一个 生物体的环境和生活方式的描述, 揭示了拥有这种特质是如何促成 繁殖成功的主人。 可以有许多合理的 听起来适应性的解释是为了解释一个特定的 特质 在这种情况下,证据很少足以起决定性作用。 形势 正是在这种情况下,社会取向, 如果你愿意的话,偏见会导致科学家倾向于一种解释, 另 在劳埃德博士研究的案例中, 人类女性性行为的研究,无论是男性科学家还是 女权主义批评家们使用了不同的适应性论点, 各自的立场。 劳埃德博士将分析这些解释, 对使用和滥用 进化生物学中的适应性解释 她的研究有望 不仅对科学哲学有很大的兴趣,而且 为进化生物学和社会科学服务。
英文摘要
Science is a social phenomena, i.e. it is done by women and men who come to their subjects with prior scientific and social commitments. Dr. Lloyd, with this grant, will be studying the affects of these prior commitments on the development of scientific theories. Her preliminary study shows that their impacts can best be seen in the gaps which necessarily exist between theoretical explanations and the available evidence. Given that there frequently is not enough evidence to firmly ground a theoretical explanation, a scientist brings to the problem both prior scientific beliefs and an inclination which has been cultivated in the society in which the science is developed for one kind of explanation over another. An example of such a development is the field of eugenics. Scientists took the available evidence from genetics and assimilated it with the racial and cultural biases which were cultivated in late 19th and early 20th century society and developed a theory for the "purification" and perfection of the human race. While consequences are not normally as extreme as in the case of eugenics, these factors clearly have an effect to a greater or lesser degree throughout science. Dr. Lloyd is examining the impact of the prior commitments of scientists in the development of their scientific explanations in evolutionary biology. The theoretical commitment which she is examining is that of "adaptationist" explanations. "Adaptive" stories in which a particular trait or property is assumed to have resulted from the direct operation of natural selection are the most prominent sort of evolutionary explanations. The traits themselves are seen as adaptations and the explanatory game is to provide a description of the environment and lifestyle of the organism which reveal how the possession of the trait would have contributed to the reproductive success of its owner. There can be a number of rational sounding adaptive explanations developed to explain a particular trait. Evidence is rarely sufficient to be determinative in such a situation. It is in such a situation that social orientations, biases if you will, lead scientists to prefer one explanation over another. In the case which Dr. Lloyd is studying, the unique aspects of female sexuality in humans, both male scientists and their feminist critics have used differing adaptive arguments for their respective positions. Dr. Lloyd will analyze these explanations in the context of a more general discussion of the use and abuse of adaptive explanations in evolutionary biology. Her study promises to be of great interest not only for the philosophy of science, but also for evolutionary biology and the social sciences.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Comparing Regional with Global Models in Atmospheric Science
-
批准号:1632202
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$22.16万
-
财政年份:2016
-
负责人:Elisabeth Lloyd
-
依托单位:
Case Study of Objectivity in Science: Climate Change
-
批准号:0646253
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$11.55万
-
财政年份:2007
-
负责人:Elisabeth Lloyd
-
依托单位:
Dissertation Research: Science as Social Action: The Search for the Hematopoietic Stem Cell
-
批准号:0620993
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$0.62万
-
财政年份:2006
-
负责人:Elisabeth Lloyd
-
依托单位:
Future Directions in the History, Philosophy, and Social Studies of Biology
-
批准号:0620799
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$1.04万
-
财政年份:2006
-
负责人:Elisabeth Lloyd
-
依托单位:
The Confirmation of Scientific Theories
-
批准号:8607170
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$0.9万
-
财政年份:1986
-
负责人:Elisabeth Lloyd
-
依托单位:
海外基金