课题基金 / 基金详情

Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: States Within States: The Social Contracts of Armed Groups

Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: States Within States: The Social Contracts of Armed Groups
政治学博士论文研究:国中之国:武装团体的社会契约
批准号:
1024414
负责人:
David Lake
金额:
$0.76万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2010
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2010-07-01 至 2011-06-30

项目摘要

项目成果

David Lake的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
所有反叛组织都需要资源。他们不仅要作为战斗力量生存下来,而且他们越强大,他们就越能与国家进行政治谈判。在缺乏可掠夺资源的情况下,叛乱分子要么通过与平民支持者的共生交换,要么通过强制从平民中榨取资源来获取资源。反政府武装如何以及为什么以不同的方式与平民建立关系尚不清楚。在这个模型中,反叛者被视为政策寻求型组织,它们对自己的意识形态目标和组织需求进行优化。在这方面,他们面临着许多与国家相同的挑战,而叛军如何应对这一挑战将影响叛军与平民的关系。叛军可以向外部势力——外国势力、侨民、跨国宗教运动——或当地公民寻求资源。平衡目标和需求是一个困难的政治现实。叛军可能会被迫在某些目标上妥协,以增加他们的资源。这些最终目标越接近平民的偏好,反政府武装就会成为越好的州长。善治可以包括政治/意识形态代表,以及一些公共服务——包括保护,以及通常由国家提供的全部社会服务。总体而言,国内支持的反叛组织有望提供最好的治理,其次是那些有宗教/种族散居者支持的反叛组织,其次是外国政府的支持,最后是极端的跨国运动。利用棉兰老岛(菲律宾南部)的自然准实验的比较力量,该项目概述了叛乱分子如何在国内外建立关系契约,以及它们如何在地面上塑造叛乱分子的治理模式。本项目使用定性和定量数据比较棉兰老岛的三个分离主义运动如何应对不同的战略环境,以及叛乱分子的行为如何随着时间和村庄的变化而变化。该研究对棉兰老岛受冲突影响地区进行了广泛调查,并进行了大量定性访谈,以比较和概述反叛组织如何提供治理。现有的叛军治理研究未能充分解释群体之间的差异,和/或限制国际或民间行动者的作用。该项目通过建立一个包括国内和国际行动者的偏好和行动的模型,从理论上为叛乱研究做出了贡献。从经验上看,这个项目在世界上运行时间最长、研究最不足的叛乱之一中使用了案例变异。利用案例内的差异保持了一系列社会经济和文化变量的不变,这些变量经常困扰着跨国比较叛乱者在当地的行为。更好地了解叛军如何建立和建立治理,不仅可以为更合适的安全和人道主义项目提供信息,还可以为政治解决方案提供建议,使现有的基础设施更加透明,从而使和平更有可能在实地持续下去。从历史上看,许多和平协议都未能落实。确定平行的治理形式、它们如何工作、它们提供什么好处以及它们为何不同,可以更有效地融入冲突后的稳定工作。
英文摘要
All rebel organizations need resources. They must not only survive as fighting forces, but the stronger they are, the better the political bargain they can negotiate with the state. In the absence of lootable resources, rebels acquire resources either through symbiotic exchange with civilian supporters or coercive extraction from civilian populations. How and why rebels structure their relations with civilians differently is not well understood. In this model, rebels are treated as policy-seeking organizations that optimize over their ideological goals and organizational needs. In this, they face many of the same challenges as states, and how rebels meet this challenge has ramifications for rebel-civilian relations. Rebels can appeal to external parties -- foreign powers, diasporas, transnational religious movements -- or local citizens for resources. Balancing goals and needs is a difficult political reality. Rebels may be forced to compromise some of their goals in order to increase their resources. The closer these resultant goals are to civilian preferences, the better governors rebels will be. Good governance can comprise political/ideological representation, as well as some public services -- including protection, and up to and including the full range of social services normally provided by states. Overall, rebel groups with domestic sponsorship are expected to provide the best governance, those with religious/ethnic diasporic support to be next-best, followed by foreign state sponsors, and finally extreme transnational movements.Leveraging the comparative power of a natural quasi-experiment in Mindanao (in the south of the Philippines), this project outlines how rebels forge relational contracts at home and abroad, and how they shape the pattern of rebel governance on the ground. This project uses qualitative and quantitative data to compare how Mindanao's three separatist movements respond to different strategic environments, as well as how rebels' behavior shifts over time, and from village to village. The study utilizes an extensive survey of Mindanao's conflict-affected areas, as well as extensive qualitative interviews to compare and outline how rebel groups provide governance.Existing studies of rebel governance fail to adequately explain variation among groups, and/or limit the role of either international or civilian actors. This project contributes theoretically to the study of insurgency by developing a model that includes the preferences and actions of both domestic and international actors. Empirically, this project uses within-case variation in one of the longest-running and most under-studied rebellions in the world. Leveraging within-case variation holds constant a range of socioeconomic and cultural variables that often bedevil cross-national comparisons of rebels' local behavior. A better understanding of how rebels build and establish governance not only can inform more appropriate security and humanitarian programs, but also can suggest ways that political settlements might incorporate and make more transparent existing infrastructures--making peace more likely to last on the ground. Historically, many peace agreements have failed to percolate to the ground. Identifying parallel forms of governance, how they work, what benefits they provide, and why they vary can allow more effective integration into post-conflict stabilization efforts.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: Treaty Compliance, Enforcement and Monitoring: A Preference-Based Approach
  • 批准号:
    1064108
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $1.2万
  • 财政年份:
    2011
  • 负责人:
    David Lake
  • 依托单位:
Doctoral Dissertation Research in Political Science: Social Networks and Electoral Strategies in the Philippines
  • 批准号:
    1023568
  • 项目类别:
    Standard Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $1.0万
  • 财政年份:
    2010
  • 负责人:
    David Lake
  • 依托单位:
海外基金