Cognitive Barriers to Understanding Complexity in Human-Technical Systems: Evidence from Engineering Students and Practitioners
Cognitive Barriers to Understanding Complexity in Human-Technical Systems: Evidence from Engineering Students and Practitioners
批准号:
1824594
负责人:
Konstantinos Triantis
金额:
$40.32万
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2018
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2018-09-15 至 2023-08-31
中文摘要
根据美国国家工程院的说法,对复杂的人-技术系统--即具有许多相互作用的部件的系统--缺乏了解,一直是造成包括例如福岛第一核电站事故和墨西哥湾深水地平线漏油事件在内的“人为灾难”的主要原因。各种研究表明,即使是受过良好教育的工程师也难以理解复杂的人类技术系统的基本概念。这项研究将为工科学生和在职专业人员提供对理解复杂系统的重要认知(如推理、思维)技能的见解。例如,认知障碍的例子有,专家倾向于着眼于细节而忽视整体,以及人类倾向于关注短期而不是长期结果,等等。这项研究将满足行业和政府的需求,为美国劳动力教育和开发复杂的问题解决者,以使美国保持其经济竞争力、国家安全和全球创新领导者的地位。鉴于工程师在其整个职业生涯中设计、构建和管理人类技术系统,研究他们在正规教育期间和之后的认知障碍的影响是很重要的。从教育的角度来看,研究将把研究结果整合到工程课程、案例研究、团队作业和模拟平台中。从推广的角度来看,这项研究将把研究结果用于公司、政府机构和大学工作室的设计和提供。这是一个多学科的项目,位于复杂系统和工程教育的交叉点上,将研究不同教育经验的本科生以及具有不同工作经验的专业人员。系统思维的中心概念化是对复杂的相互关联的社会技术系统的工作原理的理解。在我们的项目中,我们的特定定义与系统动力学学派的思想一致,该学派为分析系统行为提供了既定的方法,其最终行为随着时间的推移可能是违反直觉的。这项研究假设工程师能够识别和管理系统的复杂性,课堂教育和实地经验对于学习如何理解复杂系统是必不可少的。研究的中心假设是,工程项目的教育和现实世界的经验影响(积极或消极的)工程师对复杂系统的理解。为了验证主要假设,本文研究了四个具体的研究问题(RQ1-RQ4)。将使用三个代表工程任务的不同结构和复杂程度的小插曲。研究问题如下:RQ1:工科学生/专业人员的教育/专业水平与他们在三个问题结构和复杂性方面不同的小场景上的表现有什么关系?RQ2:工科学生/专业人员对自己的系统思维能力的看法与他们在三个问题结构和复杂性方面不同的小场景上的表现之间有什么关系?RQ3:工科学生和专业人士在解决问题的方法上有何不同,这些问题在问题的结构性和复杂性方面各有不同?和RQ4:工程学学生和专业人士如何描述他们如何以及在哪里发展了他们理解复杂系统的认知技能?该奖项反映了NSF的法定使命,并通过使用基金会的智力优势和更广泛的影响审查标准进行评估,被认为值得支持。
英文摘要
According to the National Academy of Engineering, poor understanding of complex human-technical systems, i.e., systems that have many interacting parts, has been a major cause of "man made disasters" that include, for example, the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear accident and the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. Various studies show that even well-schooled engineers have difficulty understanding basic concepts of complex human-technical systems. This research will provide insights of the important cognitive (e.g. reasoning, thinking) skills for the understanding of complex systems for both engineering students and working professionals. Examples of cognitive barriers are for example, the experts' tendency to look at details at the expense of looking at the big picture, and the human tendency to focus on short-term as opposed to the long-term outcomes, among others. This research will address the needs of industry and government to educate and develop complex problem solvers for the US workforce so that the US maintains its economic competitiveness, national security, and position as a global leader in innovation. Given that engineers design, build and manage human-technical systems throughout their careers, it is important to study the effect of the cognitive barriers during and after their formal education. From an educational point of view, the research will integrate the results into engineering courses, case studies, team assignments and simulation platforms. From an outreach point of view, the research will use the results for the design and offering of company, government agency, and University workshops.This is a multi-disciplinary project, which lies at the intersection of complex systems and engineering education and will study undergraduate students with different educational experiences as well as professionals with different work experiences. Central conceptualizations of systems thinking is the focus on understanding the workings of complex interconnected socio-technical systems. In our project, our specific definition aligns with the system dynamics school of thought, which provides established methods for analyzing system behavior whose final behavior over time might be counter-intuitive. The research assumes that engineers can recognize and manage system complexity and that classroom education and field experiences can be essential for learning how to understand complex systems. The central research hypothesis is that education in engineering programs and real world experiences influence (positively or negatively) engineers' understanding of complex systems. In order to investigate the main hypothesis, four specific research questions (RQ1-RQ4) are studied. Three vignettes with different levels of structuredness and complexity representing engineering tasks will be used. The research questions are as follows: RQ1: What is the relationship between engineering students'/professionals' level of education/expertise and their performance on three vignettes that vary with respect to problem structuredness and complexity? RQ2: What is the relationship between engineering students'/professionals' perceptions of their own systems thinking competencies and their performance on three vignettes that vary with respect to problem structuredness and complexity? RQ3: How do engineering students and professionals differ in their approaches to solving problems that vary with respect to problem stucturedness and complexity? and RQ4: How do engineering students and professionals describe how and where they developed their cognitive skills of understanding complex systems?This award reflects NSF's statutory mission and has been deemed worthy of support through evaluation using the Foundation's intellectual merit and broader impacts review criteria.
期刊论文(1)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Comparing Self-Report Assessments and Scenario-Based Assessments of Systems Thinking Competence
比较系统思维能力的自我报告评估和基于情景的评估
DOI:
10.1007/s10956-023-10027-2
发表时间:
2023
期刊:
Journal of Science Education and Technology
影响因子:
4.4
作者:
[Davis, Kirsten A., Grote, Dustin, Mahmoudi, Hesam, Perry, Logan, Ghaffarzadegan, Navid, Grohs, Jacob, Hosseinichimeh, Niyousha, Knight, David B., Triantis, Konstantinos]
通讯作者:
Triantis, Konstantinos
LEAP-HI: Safety and Learning from Errors and Near Misses in the Human-Automation Interaction of Socio-Technical Infrastructure Systems
-
批准号:2051685
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$200.0万
-
财政年份:2021
-
负责人:Konstantinos Triantis
-
依托单位:
Workshop: Investigation of the Theoretical Foundations in Systems Engineering; Frost, West Virginia; October 2015
-
批准号:1548480
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$4.95万
-
财政年份:2015
-
负责人:Konstantinos Triantis
-
依托单位:
Collaborative Research: Multi-Perspective Evacuation Performance Measurement
-
批准号:1536808
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$35.69万
-
财政年份:2015
-
负责人:Konstantinos Triantis
-
依托单位:
海外基金