FAI: Quantifying Direct and Indirect Consequences of Racial Disparities in Outcomes Following Cardiac Surgery
FAI: Quantifying Direct and Indirect Consequences of Racial Disparities in Outcomes Following Cardiac Surgery
批准号:
1939675
负责人:
Ilya Shpitser
金额:
$16.97万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
美国
项目类别:
Standard Grant
财政年份:
2020
资助国家:
美国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2020-01-01 至 2020-12-31
中文摘要
随着学习算法在我们的生活中变得无处不在,观察者和业内人士都对潜在的有害或歧视性偏见和差异表示担忧。当算法以不恰当的方式使用数据中的敏感特征(如种族、年龄、性别或性取向)时,可能会出现这些问题。令人不安的种族差异已被发现与多种健康结果有关。特别是,众所周知,与其他族裔相比,非洲裔美国人患冠心病的比例更高,并且在接受手术干预后,其术后发病率和死亡率也更高。虽然这些差异在文献中得到了很好的证实,但它们在多大程度上是由生物因素、社会经济因素或所提供的护理差异造成的,目前尚不清楚。该提案将通过结合因果中介分析和公平意识算法的工具以及从电子健康记录中获得的丰富数据集,解决评估和解决健康结果差异原因方面的概念、方法和实践差距。这将确保在医疗保健环境中用于预测和决策支持的学习算法的好处公平地适用于所有人。此外,作为该项目的一部分,该项目将允许在大学的数据科学课程中引入差异和算法公平性。本研究中开发的用于量化和解决差异的方法和实践创新对于确保医疗保健环境中用于预测和决策支持的学习算法的好处公平公正地适用于所有人至关重要。在提议的项目中,关于差异和公平性的观点建立在团队的初步工作之上,其中公平性约束对应于因果模型中沿着某些(特定领域)“不允许”路径消失的因果效应。因果建模的正式框架允许团队根据因果路径特定效应(pse)来数学化(非)公平性标准,这些效应可以从观察到的数据中估计出来,然后作为优化任务的约束施加。该项目将严格证明所提议的框架的合理性,明确提出的公平约束的形式化(与以前的提议不同)是如何设计的,以干预不公正的循环。重要的是,我们将在这里借鉴道德哲学和科学哲学的相关文献,因为关键概念——公平、系统性不公正、因果解释——几十年来一直是哲学中争论和分析的主题。为了解决先前工作的局限性,即只允许相对简单的参数模型的高质量解决方案,或者需要诸如拒绝抽样等棘手的方法,本项目开发了新的方法,该方法将使用因果推理中的结构嵌套模型和统计中的经验似然的技术来重新表述最大似然框架中的问题。这些方法将更容易可靠地扩展到高维数据,并且对预测和策略学习问题产生比以前更高质量的解决方案。这将使我们评估和满足公平性约束的方法适用于医疗保健中发现的复杂数据。最后,本项目将把开发的方法应用于心脏手术患者的数据,并进行初步分析,旨在评估差异在多大程度上可归因于与生物学、社会经济地位和护理差异相关的途径。临床小组将开始验证模型和结果。虽然算法公平是机器学习社区非常感兴趣的话题,但已经探索了多种方法,该提案在三个方面是独特的。首先,提议的框架动机良好,并提供了一种系统的方法来评估不同的,有时是相互冲突的直觉,这些直觉是先前建议的基础。其次,该项目旨在打破正式意义上的不公正循环。最后,提出的公平推理方法不是对问题的单一方法的增量扩展,而是借鉴了多个社区的见解,并且可以被视为分析哲学,因果推理,半参数统计和优化工具的新组合。该奖项反映了美国国家科学基金会的法定使命,并通过使用基金会的知识价值和更广泛的影响审查标准进行评估,被认为值得支持。
英文摘要
As learning algorithms become ubiquitous in our lives, both observers and insiders have expressed concerns about the potentially harmful or discriminatory biases and disparities. These issues may arise when algorithms use sensitive features in the data, such as race, age, gender, or sexual orientation, in inappropriate ways. Troubling racial disparities have been discovered for many kinds of health outcomes. In particular, it is known that African Americans have a higher prevalence of coronary heart disease compared to other ethnic groups, and are known to suffer higher rates of post-operative morbidity and mortality, after undergoing surgical interventions. While these disparities are well established in the literature, the extent to which they are due to biological factors, socioeconomic factors, or differences in offered care is not known. This proposal will address the conceptual, methodological, and practical gaps in assessing and addressing reasons for disparities in health outcomes by a combination of tools from causal mediation analysis and fairness-aware algorithms, and a rich dataset obtained from electronic health records. This will ensure the benefits of learning algorithms used for prediction and decision support in healthcare settings apply fairly and equitably to all. In addition, as part of the project, the project will allow for the introduction of disparities and algorithmic fairness into the data science curriculum at the university. Methodological and practical innovations for quantifying and addressing disparities developed in this research are crucial to make sure the benefits of learning algorithms used for prediction and decision support in healthcare settings apply fairly and equitably to all.The perspective on disparities and fairness in the proposed project builds on the team's preliminary work where fairness constraints correspond to vanishing causal effects along certain (domain-specific) "impermissible" pathways in a causal model. The formal framework of causal modeling has allowed the team to mathematize (un)fairness criteria in terms of causal path-specific effects (PSEs) that can be estimated from observed data, and then imposed as constraints on the optimization task. The project will rigorously justify the proposed framework, making precise how the proposed formalization of fairness constraints (unlike previous proposals) is designed to intervene on cycles of injustice. Importantly we will draw on the relevant literature from moral philosophy and philosophy of science here, since the crucial concepts -- fairness, systemic injustice, causal explanation -- have been the subject of much debate and analysis in philosophy for decades. To address the limitations of prior work, which only allowed high quality solutions for relatively simple parametric models, or entailed intractable methods such as rejection sampling, this project develops novel methodology that will use techniques from structural nested models in causal inference and empirical likelihood in statistics to rephrase the problem in the framework of maximum likelihood. These methods will be easier to reliably scale to high dimensional data, and yield much higher quality solutions to both prediction and policy learning problems than previously possible. This will make our methodology for assessing and satisfying fairness constraints applicable to complex data found in healthcare. Finally, this project will apply the developed methodology to data on patients that have undergone heart surgery, and perform preliminary analyses that aim to assess the extent to which disparities are attributable to pathways associated with biology, socioeconomic status, and differences in care. The clinical team will begin to validate the models and the resulting findings. While algorithmic fairness is a topic of considerable interest to the machine learning community, with multiple approaches already explored, this proposal is unique in three ways. First, the proposed framework is well-motivated, and provides a systematic way to evaluate disparate and sometimes conflicting intuitions that underly previous proposals. Second, the project is designed to break the cycles of injustice in a formal sense. Finally, the proposed approach to fair inference is not an incremental extension of a single method to the problem, but draws on insights from multiple communities, and can be viewed as a novel combination of tools from analytic philosophy, causal inference, semi-parametric statistics, and optimization.This award reflects NSF's statutory mission and has been deemed worthy of support through evaluation using the Foundation's intellectual merit and broader impacts review criteria.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
FAI: causal and semi-parametric inference for explanations of disparities and disparity-correcting modeling
-
批准号:2040804
-
项目类别:Standard Grant
-
资助金额:$39.99万
-
财政年份:2021
-
负责人:Ilya Shpitser
-
依托单位:
CAREER: Robust Causal And Statistical Inference In High Dimensional Structured Systems With Hidden Variables
-
批准号:1942239
-
项目类别:Continuing Grant
-
资助金额:$55.0万
-
财政年份:2020
-
负责人:Ilya Shpitser
-
依托单位:
海外基金