课题基金 / 基金详情

Accuracy of confidence: Relationship with decision-making and decision outcomes in a complex social-ecological system

Accuracy of confidence: Relationship with decision-making and decision outcomes in a complex social-ecological system
置信度的准确性:复杂社会生态系统中决策和决策结果的关系
批准号:
419459396
负责人:
Dr. Helen Fischer
金额:
$0.0万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
德国
项目类别:
Research Fellowships
财政年份:
2018
资助国家:
德国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2017-12-31 至 2020-12-31

项目摘要

项目成果

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
当在危险和不确定的环境中做出决定时,人们对情况的理解的信心程度会影响决策,通常比理解程度本身更重要。这种影响存在于医疗、金融和政治等不同领域,也存在于群体决策中,在这些领域,人们也会利用他人的信心来指导自己的决定。例如,对自己诊断的准确性过于自信的医生不太可能寻找额外的诊断信息,高估自己的专业水平的官僚更有可能支持冒险政策,人们更多地听从更自信的建议者的建议。尽管是高风险决策、不确定环境以及自然涉及群体决策的主要例子,但对人类如何集体管理公共资源使用的研究在很大程度上忽略了对理解的信心的潜在影响。这里将讨论三个基本问题:当决定使用公共资源时,自己对理解资源动态(资源随时间的发展)的信心是否可以预测决策,即使在控制理解的情况下也是如此?其他小组成员的信心是否预示着他们自己的决定,即使他们的信心是没有根据的?潜在的信心驱动决策与集团在可持续管理资源方面的成功有何关系?将采取多实验、多方法的方法来提供可靠的答案,方法是:(I)分析现有的实验数据,其中群体在外部不同的风险水平下共同管理共同资源;(Ii)进行专门设计的后续实验,允许调查作为群体互动功能的最先进的理解和信心衡量标准的变化;以及(Iii)计算建模方法,其中可能的基于信心的决策策略被形式化,并与行为数据进行比较。总而言之,该项目将有助于我们理解是什么推动了个人和群体对共用资源使用的决策,并将对解释这些高风险决策的理解与信心的相对权重做出可靠的估计。
英文摘要
When making decisions in risky and uncertain environments, the level of confidence humans have in their understanding of the situation influences decision-making, often more so than the level of understanding itself. This effect exists in areas as diverse as medicine, finance, and politics, as well as in group decision-making, where people also use other’s confidence to guide own decisions. For example, physicians who are overconfident about the accuracy of their diagnosis are less likely to seek out additional diagnostic information, bureaucrats who overestimate their level of expertise are more likely to endorse risk-taking policies, and people follow more the advices of more confident advice-givers. Despite being a prime example of risky decisions, uncertain environments, and naturally involving group decision-making, research on how humans collectively manage the use of common-pool resources, however, has largely neglected the potential influence of confidence in understanding. Here three fundamental questions will be addressed: When deciding about the use of a common resource, does own confidence in understanding the resource dynamics (development of the resource over time) predict decisions, even when controlling for understanding? Does other group members’ confidence predict own decisions, potentially even when their confidence is unwarranted? How do potentially confidence-driven decisions relate to groups’ success in sustainably managing the resource? A multi-experiment, multi-method approach will be taken to deliver robust answers by (i) analyzing existing experimental data where groups of people collectively managed a common resource under externally varied levels of risk; (ii) conducting a specifically designed follow-up experiment that allows for investigating changes in state-of the art measures of understanding and confidence as a function of group interaction; and (iii) a computational modeling approach where possible confidence-based decision strategies are formalized and compared against the behavioral data. In sum, the project will contribute to our understanding of what drives individual and group decisions on common-pool resource use, and will deliver solid estimates of the relative weights of understanding versus confidence in explaining these risky decisions.
期刊论文(0)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
海外基金