课题基金 / 基金详情

The Doubting Jew: Atheism, Jewish Thought and Interfaith Relations

The Doubting Jew: Atheism, Jewish Thought and Interfaith Relations
怀疑的犹太人:无神论、犹太思想和宗教间关系
批准号:
AH/N002881/1
负责人:
Daniel Langton
金额:
$17.83万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Fellowship
财政年份:
2016
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2016 至 --

项目摘要

项目成果

Daniel Langton的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
对犹太人怀疑的研究将集中在无神论和犹太教之间的相遇。无神论与怀疑论、哲学唯物主义和科学自然主义等相关哲学一起,是西方思想和社会中最具影响力的思想思潮之一。因此,在任何试图将后者定位于现代世界的宗教研究中,这是一个非常重要的现象,不容忽视。对于研究犹太教和犹太人的学者来说,这个问题更为紧迫,因为对于犹太人来说,众所周知,宗教和种族的类别模糊,因此谈论非犹太犹太人是有道理的,他们中的许多人在历史上对宗教漠不关心,甚至怀有敌意。非宗教哲学和宗教之间的跨文化交流对美国犹太教的主要形式的研究特别感兴趣,即改革犹太教,自19世纪初以来,它一直表现为对现代性的回应。同样,在现代,犹太人和基督徒之间的不同信仰的相遇发生在很大程度上是无神论和唯物主义文化的背景下;人们甚至可以说,伴随他们的还有一个始终存在的第三个对话伙伴,即宗教怀疑论者。这些观察结果促使我们提出以下问题:为什么还没有对犹太人与无神论的接触进行实质性的调查?这样的调查将填补无神论的历史研究和随之而来的宗教-无神论争议的一个重要空白。它还将加强对现代犹太人身份的理解,包括那些接受和反对无神论论点的人。为什么没有改革派或自由派犹太教的主要研究将怀疑作为分析范畴?这样的研究可能会修改对犹太教进步形式发展的历史理解。虽然改革的出现通常被认为是对现代性的回应-à-vis正统犹太传统和基督教,但人们可能同样容易关注怀疑的话语,特别是围绕无神论、怀疑主义和唯物主义哲学。3. 为什么研究犹太教和基督教关系的历史学家忽视了无神论的现象?这样的研究将为宗教间关系的学术研究开辟一条新的途径,尽管无神论在公开的基督教神学话语中备受关注,而且自启蒙运动以来,犹太人一直有一种强烈的倾向,即通过基督教思想来解决他们对现代性的反应,但迄今为止,这一研究一直被忽视。这里的提议代表了一项计划,将西方犹太神学对现代无神论和怀疑主义的回应汇集在一起,其中一些不容易获得或在公共领域。这样的著作之所以重要,不仅是因为现代无神论历史中关于犹太人的章节缺失了,而且因为所涉及的原始材料对于研究进步犹太教的历史学家以及理解现代犹太教和基督教思想之间复杂的相互关系来说,是一种未被充分利用的资源。人们会期望这样的第一手资料的集合是所有三个领域的历史学家熟悉和经常使用的资源,但事实并非如此。
英文摘要
The proposed study of Jewish doubt will focus on the encounter between atheism and the religion of Judaism. Along with the related philosophies including scepticism, philosophical materialism and scientific naturalism, atheism is amongst the most influential intellectual trends in Western thought and society. As such, it is too important a phenomenon to ignore in any study of religion that seeks to locate the latter within the modern world. For scholars of Judaism and the Jewish people, the issue is even more pressing in that for Jews, famously, the categories of religion and ethnicity blur so that it makes sense to speak of non-Jewish Jews many of whom have historically been indifferent or even hostile to religion. The intercultural intercourse between non-religious philosophies and religion is of particular interest in the study of the dominant form of Judaism in the US, that of Reform Judaism, which since the early nineteenth-century has presented itself as a response to modernity. Likewise, interfaith encounters between Jew and Christian have in modern times taken place against the backdrop of a largely atheistic, materialist culture; one might even say that they have been accompanied by an ever-present third partner in dialogue, namely, the religious doubter. These observations prompt us to ask:1. Why has no substantial survey of the Jewish engagement with atheism yet been undertaken? Such a survey would fill an important gap in the historical study of atheism and the attendant religion-atheism controversy. It would also enhance an understanding of modern Jewish identity among those who both embraced and those who opposed atheistic arguments.2. Why have no major studies of Reform or Liberal Judaism used doubt as a category of analysis? Such a study would likely revise the historical understanding of the development of progressive forms of Judaism. While the emergence of Reform is usually presented as a response to modernity vis-à-vis Orthodox Jewish tradition and Christianity, one might just as readily focus upon discourses of doubt, specifically around atheism, scepticism and materialistic philosophies. 3. Why has the phenomenon of atheism has been overlooked by historians of Jewish-Christian relations? Such a study would open up a new avenue of research for scholarship of interfaith relations, ignored until now despite the high profile atheism has been given in public Christian theological discourse and the fact that, since the Enlightenment, there has been a strong tendency for Jews to work out their responses to modernity in relation to Christian thought.The proposal here represents a programme to bring together Western Jewish theological responses to atheism and scepticism in the modern period, a number of which are not easily available or in the public domain. Such a body of work would be important not just because the Jewish chapter of the modern history of atheism is missing, but because the primary source materials involved represent an underutilized resource for historians of progressive Judaism and for understanding the complicated interrelationship of modern Jewish and Christian thought. One would have expected such a collection of primary sources to be a familiar and regularly used resource for historians of all three areas, but this is not the case.
期刊论文(7)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Atheism in Five Minutes
五分钟了解无神论
DOI: --
发表时间: 2022
期刊:
影响因子: --
作者: [Langton, DR]
通讯作者: Langton, DR
Encyclopedia of Jewish-Christian Relations
犹太教与基督教关系百科全书
DOI: --
发表时间: 2021
期刊:
影响因子: --
作者: [Langton, DR]
通讯作者: Langton, DR
Atheism, Scepticism and Challenges to Monotheism
无神论、怀疑论和对一神论的挑战
DOI: --
发表时间: 2016
期刊:
影响因子: --
作者: [Langton, DR]
通讯作者: Langton, DR
Discourses of Doubt: The Place of Atheism, Skepticism, and Infidelity in Nineteenth-century North American Reform Jewish Thought
怀疑的话语:无神论、怀疑论和不忠在十九世纪北美改革派犹太思想中的地位
DOI: 10.15650/hebruniocollannu.88.2017.0203
发表时间: 2017
期刊: Hebrew Union College Annual
影响因子: --
作者: [Daniel R. Langton]
通讯作者: Daniel R. Langton
共 7 条
    CDA-Nonconformity in Minority Communities:Representations of the Anglo-Jewish Experience in the Oral Testimony Archive of the Manchester Jewish Museum
    • 批准号:
      AH/I505121/1
    • 项目类别:
      Training Grant
    • 资助金额:
      $7.04万
    • 财政年份:
      2010
    • 负责人:
      Daniel Langton
    • 依托单位:
    The Apostle Paul in the Jewish Imagination: A Study in Ideology
    • 批准号:
      AH/D501482/1
    • 项目类别:
      Research Grant
    • 资助金额:
      $2.95万
    • 财政年份:
      2007
    • 负责人:
      Daniel Langton
    • 依托单位:
    海外基金