Causal inference in infectious disease prevention studies

传染病预防研究中的因果推断

• 批准号: 7993542
• 负责人: Michael G Hudgens
• 金额: $ 30.73万
• 依托单位: UNIV OF NORTH CAROLINA CHAPEL HILL
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 财政年份: 2009
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2009-12-01 至 2013-11-30
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://reporter.nih.gov/project-details/7993542
• 关键词: Affect; Area; Bangladesh; Cessation of life; Child; Cholera Vaccine; Communicable Diseases; Confidence Intervals; Data; Data Analyses; Data Set; Development; Event; HIV; Health; Health Policy; Individual; Infection; Intervention; Lead; Malawi; Measures; Methodology; Methods; Mothers; Observational Study; Outcome; Pertussis; Public Health; Research; Research Personnel; Risk; Sampling; Senegal; Statistical Methods; Stratification; Testing; Time; Vaccinated; Vaccination; Vaccine Clinical Trial; Vaccines; Vertical Disease Transmission; Weaning; antiretroviral therapy; conditioning; disorder control; disorder prevention; improved; interest; intervention effect; postnatal; prevent; public health relevance; transmission process; vaccine effectiveness

DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): The overall objective of this research is to develop statistical methods for quantifying the effects of interventions to prevent infectious diseases. The main motivating examples are studies of vaccine effectiveness. Two particularly challenging problems in vaccine studies entail assessing (i) indirect effects of vaccination and (ii) vaccine effects on post-infection endpoints. Evaluating (i) is a non-standard problem because indirect effects measure the effect of vaccinating one individual on another individual's health outcome. Assessing (ii) is challenging because infected vaccinees may not be comparable to infected controls. This specific proposal is to adapt and develop modern causal inference methodology for use in evaluating (i) and (ii). Similar research will be conducted motivated by studies to prevent transmission of HIV from mother to child where issues similar to (ii) arise. Specific Aim 1 is to develop statistical methods in causal inference with interference for application in evaluating direct, indirect, total, and overall vaccine effects. Areas of particular emphasis will be development of nonparametric tests and confidence intervals, incorporating baseline covariates, and analysis of data from observational studies. A motivating data set is from a trial of cholera vaccines in Bangladesh. Specific Aim 2 is to develop exact statistical methods in causal inference with principal stratification for application in evaluating vaccine effects on post-infection endpoints. This research will focus on applying the ideas of principal stratification in the small sample setting under minimal assumptions. Comparisons will be conducted between the proposed methods and existing large-sample methods as well as traditional intent-to-treat approaches. The research for this aim is motivated by proof-of-concept clinical trials of vaccines where few events are expected. Specific Aim 3 is to develop causal inference methodology to assess vaccine effects on infectiousness. This research will combine aspects of Aims 1 and 2 since studies to assess vaccine effects on infectiousness typically entail conditioning on infection of primary cases (Aim 2) and the vaccination status of the primary case can affect the infection outcome in exposed close contacts (Aim 1). Methods developed in this aims will be used to estimate the causal effect of pertussis vaccination on infectiousness using data from a study in Senegal. Specific Aim 4 is to develop statistical methods for causal inference with principal stratification and competing risks. This research is motivated by studies to prevent postnatal mother-to-child transmission (MTCT) of HIV where HIV-free death and weaning are competing risks. In such studies, investigators are often interested in comparing intervention strategies conditional on survival to a certain time point such that this aim will utilize the principal stratification framework. The methods developed under this aim will be used to estimate the causal effect of antiretroviral therapy on MTCT using data from a recent study in Malawi. 1 PUBLIC HEALTH RELEVANCE: This statistical methods developed in this research will lead to improved estimation of the effects of interventions to prevent infectious diseases. Accurate and precise quantification of intervention effects are important in regulatory decisions and public health policy regarding infectious disease control.

描述（由申请人提供）：本研究的总体目标是开发量化干预措施预防传染病效果的统计方法。主要的激励例子是疫苗有效性的研究。疫苗研究中两个特别具有挑战性的问题需要评估（i）疫苗接种的间接影响和（ii）疫苗对感染后终点的影响。评估（i）是一个非标准问题，因为间接效应衡量的是一个人接种疫苗对另一个人健康结果的影响。评估（ii）是具有挑战性的，因为感染的疫苗接种者可能无法与感染的对照组进行比较。这个具体建议是调整和发展现代因果推理方法，用于评估（i）和（ii）。将开展类似的研究，其动机是在出现类似（ii）的问题时预防艾滋病毒母婴传播。具体目标1是开发具有干扰的因果推断的统计方法，用于评价直接、间接、总体和整体疫苗效应。特别强调的领域将是非参数检验和置信区间的发展，纳入基线协变量，并分析观察性研究的数据。一组鼓舞人心的数据来自孟加拉国的霍乱疫苗试验。具体目标2是开发因果推断的精确统计方法，主要分层用于评价疫苗对感染后终点的影响。本研究将重点关注在最小假设下在小样本环境中应用主分层的想法。将所提出的方法和现有的大样本方法以及传统的意向治疗方法之间进行比较。这一目标的研究是由疫苗的概念验证临床试验推动的，预计这些试验很少发生事件。具体目标3是开发因果推断方法，以评估疫苗对传染性的影响。本研究将结合目标1和目标2的联合收割机方面，因为评估疫苗对传染性影响的研究通常需要对原发病例的感染进行调节（目标2），并且原发病例的疫苗接种状态可能影响暴露密切接触者的感染结局（目标1）。为此目的开发的方法将使用塞内加尔研究的数据来估计百日咳疫苗接种对传染性的因果影响。具体目标4是开发统计方法，用于主要分层和竞争风险的因果推断。这项研究的动机是研究预防产后母婴传播艾滋病毒，其中无艾滋病毒死亡和断奶是相互竞争的风险。在这些研究中，研究者通常对比较以某个时间点的生存率为条件的干预策略感兴趣，因此这一目标将利用主要分层框架。在这一目标下开发的方法将用于利用最近在马拉维进行的一项研究的数据估计抗逆转录病毒疗法对母婴传播的因果影响。1 公共卫生关系：本研究中开发的统计方法将有助于更好地估计预防传染病的干预措施的效果。准确和精确地量化干预效果在传染病控制的监管决策和公共卫生政策中非常重要。