Achievements of dialogic-participatory procedures- Meta-analytical Pilot Study on Participatory Budgeting and Local Agenda 21 in Germany

对话参与程序的成就 - 德国参与式预算和地方 21 世纪议程元分析试点研究

• 批准号: 257469979
• 负责人: Professorin Dr. Brigitte Geißel
• 金额: --
• 依托单位: Arbeitsbereich Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft
• 依托单位国家: 德国
• 项目类别: Research Grants
• 财政年份: 2014
• 资助国家: 德国
• 起止时间: 2013-12-31 至 2015-12-31
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://gepris.dfg.de/gepris/projekt/257469979?language=en
• 关键词: Achievements; dialogic; participatory; procedures; Meta

Dialog-oriented, participatory procedures have been regarded for a long time either as cure to counter malaises of representative democracy or it was doubted whether these procedures make sense. The planned pilot study will bring empirical evidence to this polarizing, misleading debate and pursues two objectives. First, it aims at providing a systematic analysis to answer the following question: Which procedure had which achievements (micro-, meso-, macro-level) in which context? Such an evidence based study is necessary to refine and to develop theories on deliberative democracy. The pilot study will combine deliberative approaches with psychological perspectives and historical institutionalism. The second objective is a methodological one. The pilot study will examine whether metaanalyses are possible and useful in a research field with predominantly qualitative case studies. Around 100 empirical studies on dialog-oriented, participatory procedures in Germany will be standardized and quantified. We will find out which problems occur and which solutions are feasible. If the metaanalysis turns out to be practical we plan further metaanalyses with international partners.

长期以来，以对话为导向的参与性程序要么被视为消除代议制民主弊病的良方，要么被怀疑这些程序是否有意义。计划中的试点研究将为这种两极分化、误导性的辩论提供经验证据，并追求两个目标。首先，它旨在提供一个系统的分析来回答以下问题：哪个程序在哪个背景下取得了哪些成就（微观、中观、宏观层面）？这种基于证据的研究对于完善和发展协商民主理论是必要的。该试点研究将把审议方法与心理学观点和历史制度主义结合起来。第二个目标是方法论上的。试点研究将以定性案例研究为主，检验meta分析在研究领域是否可能和有用。大约100项关于德国以对话为导向的参与性程序的实证研究将被标准化和量化。我们将找出哪些问题发生了，哪些解决方案是可行的。如果荟萃分析证明是可行的，我们计划与国际合作伙伴进行进一步的荟萃分析。