课题基金 / 基金详情

The rhetorical culture of the British House of Commons, 1918-1940

The rhetorical culture of the British House of Commons, 1918-1940
英国下议院的修辞文化,1918-1940
批准号:
AH/I025298/1
负责人:
Richard Toye
金额:
$2.89万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Fellowship
财政年份:
2011
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2011 至 --

项目摘要

项目成果

Richard Toye的其他基金

相似基金

相关文献

中文摘要
翻译
两次世界大战之间的几年是政治和经济动荡的时期,但在英国,它们也以相当大的制度稳定为标志。以共产主义和法西斯主义为形式的极端主义未能站稳脚跟,选举和议会政治继续以可识别的形式存在。这并不是说一切都没有改变。事实上,这是该国全面民主的最初几年:1918年,选举权扩大到所有男性和部分女性,1928年女性终于获得平等的选举权。与此同时,工党取代自由党成为反对党的主要政党,并于1924年首次组建政府;而保守党则从战前的低迷中恢复过来,主导政治,直到1940年内维尔·张伯伦政府垮台。本研究探讨了在变化中稳定的主题如何在英国政治的一个关键竞技场-下议院中发挥作用。它考察了下议院的修辞文化--也就是围绕着议会演讲习惯的正式和非正式惯例--是如何随着时间的推移而演变的,以及它与英国政治文化的更普遍的关系。历史学家们普遍认为--这是正确的--所有三个主要政党都致力于议会方法。他们忽略了的是,构成“议会方法”的行为类型可以有各种各样的解释,并且作为党派政治的一部分受到高度争议。因此,保守党--他们自己在反对党时经常采取破坏性策略--将激进的社会主义议员的“粗暴行为”描绘成工党不适合执政的证据。然而,这些议员认为他们的行动是引起人们注意失业者困境的适当手段。相比之下,工党领袖拉姆齐·麦克唐纳(Ramsay MacDonald)试图引导他的追随者采用争议较少的方法,正是为了反击保守党对违宪的指控。与此同时,自由派则把自己描绘成唯一真正忠于议会的人:他们认为,其他政党希望践踏议会的特权,以便由他们所代表的既得利益者建立选举独裁。因此,议会举止和语言等看似平凡的问题与更广泛的政治辩论相关联,并代表着更广泛的政治辩论。因此,修辞文化的问题与历史学家关注的其他重要问题有关,例如政治家如何试图操纵“国家价值观”以获得自己的利益,以及媒体如何表现政治辩论。当然,这是一个议会程序不被广播的时代,而英国广播公司在其早期的政治报道中试图避免“争议”。然而,报纸上对下议院有广泛的报道,无论是逐字逐句的演讲报道还是速写者的简短报道。因此,我们可以了解下议院的气氛,同样重要的是,我们可以发现一些著名的事件(如1930年工党议员夺取权杖)是如何在议会外进行辩论的。还有大量其他资料来源--其中许多我已经研究过了--可以用来阐明制约议会演讲的惯例。这些作品包括日记、回忆录和漫画,以及描述公地惯例和习俗的当代作品。这些消息来源很少是中立的:他们对所发生事情的描述充满了意识形态,并试图推进某种议程。然而,如果仔细对待,它们可以产生重要的见解,让我们了解政治行为者在关于正确行为形式的争论中认为什么是危险的。我们希望这项研究将对修正我们对这一关键时期的理解做出重要贡献。
英文摘要
The interwar years were a time of political and economic turbulence, but in Britain they were also marked by considerable institutional stability. Extremism, in the form of communism and fascism, failed to gain much of a foothold, and electoral and parliamentary politics continued in a recognisable form. This is not to say that nothing changed. Indeed, these were the first years of full democracy in the country: the franchise was extended to all men and some women in 1918, women finally receiving the vote on equal terms in 1928. Meanwhile, Labour replaced the Liberals as the main party of Opposition, and formed a government for the first time in 1924; whereas the Conservatives recovered from their pre-war doldrums to dominate politics until the collapse of Neville Chamberlain's government in 1940. This research explores how the theme of stability amidst change played out in a crucial arena of British politics - the House of Commons. It examines how the rhetorical culture of the Commons - that is to say, the formal and informal conventions surrounding habits of parliamentary speech - evolved over time and how it related to British political culture more generally.Historians have generally assumed - rightly - that all three main parties were committed to parliamentary methods. What they have overlooked is that the types of behaviour that constituted 'parliamentary methods' were open to widely varying interpretations and were highly contested as part of partisan politics. Thus the Conservatives - who had themselves often engaged in disruptive tactics when in Opposition - portrayed the 'rowdyism' of radical socialist MPs as proof that Labour was unfit to govern. Those MPs, however, saw their actions as a proper means of drawing attention to the plight of the unemployed. Labour leader Ramsay MacDonald, by contrast, sought to steer his followers towards less controversial methods, precisely in order to counter Conservative charges of unconstitutionalism. Liberals, meanwhile, presented themselves as the only ones who were genuinely committed to parliament: the other parties, they argued, wished to ride roughshod over parliament's prerogatives in order to establish elective dictatorship by the vested interests they represented.Therefore, apparently mundane issues of parliamentary deportment and language intersected with, and were representative of, much wider political debates. As such, the question of rhetorical culture is related to other important issues that have preoccupied historians, such as how politicians sought to manipulate 'national values' to their own advantage, and how political debate was represented in the media. This, of course, was a time at which parliamentary proceedings were not broadcast and at which the BBC, in its early years, sought to avoid 'controversy' in its reporting of politics. There was however extensive coverage of the Commons in the newspapers, both in terms of verbatim reporting of speeches and in shorter reports by sketch-writers. It is thus possible to gain a sense of the Commons atmosphere and, equally importantly, to discover how celebrated episodes (such as the seizure of the mace by a Labour MP in 1930) were debated outside parliament. There is also a vast range of other sources - many of which I have already examined - that can be used to cast light on the conventions that governed parliamentary speech. These include diaries, memoirs and cartoons, as well contemporary works describing the routines and customs of the Commons. Few of these sources were neutral: their descriptions of what occurred were ideologically loaded, and sought to advance some kind of agenda. Treated carefully, though, they can yield important insights into what political actors felt was at stake in arguments about the correct forms of behaviour. It is hoped that this research will make an important contribution to revising our understanding of this crucial period.
期刊论文(2)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
DOI: 10.1093/tcbh/hws049
发表时间: 2012
期刊: Twentieth Century British History
影响因子: 0.9
作者: [Toye R]
通讯作者: Toye R
Genres of Political Writing in Britain since 1900
  • 批准号:
    AH/T005734/1
  • 项目类别:
    Research Grant
  • 资助金额:
    $4.05万
  • 财政年份:
    2020
  • 负责人:
    Richard Toye
  • 依托单位:
国内基金
海外基金
新型二维/三维双体系癌症研究模型的建立
  • 批准号:
    32070796
  • 项目类别:
    面上项目
  • 资助金额:
    58.0万元
  • 批准年份:
    2020
  • 负责人:
    王霞
  • 依托单位:
肝脏类器官的建立及其在移植治疗肝脏疾病中的研究
基于滋养层类器官探究早期胎盘发育
  • 批准号:
    31900572
  • 项目类别:
    青年科学基金项目
  • 资助金额:
    24.0万元
  • 批准年份:
    2019
  • 负责人:
    马启旺
  • 依托单位:
人胆囊源CD63+细胞的干性特征与分化特性的研究