Early discourse competence in preschool children: An elicitation study
Early discourse competence in preschool children: An elicitation study
批准号:
AH/D001099/1
负责人:
Cecile De Cat
金额:
$9.21万
依托单位:
依托单位国家:
英国
项目类别:
Research Grant
财政年份:
2006
资助国家:
英国
项目状态:
已结题
起止时间:
2006 至 --
中文摘要
语篇能力是指在一定的语境中能够对信息进行适当编码的语言知识,反映说话人假设听话人知道或相信的东西。人们普遍认为,学龄前儿童缺乏必要的话语能力,以成年人一样的方式编码信息。例如,实验研究认为,学龄前儿童在成人语言中只可能使用不定词的情况下使用不定词(如“the duck”)而不是不定词(“a duck”)(参见例如Maratsos 1974; Emslie &史蒂文森1981; Hickmann et al 1996)。特别是,它旨在确定学龄前儿童是否掌握了话题的话语概念-一个从未被实验证实的主张,在De Cat(2002)。主题表达句子的内容。在法语口语中,话题是强制性错位的:它们出现在句子的外围--由(1)中的逗号表示--并由句子内部的一个元素(这里是“il”)恢复。话题必须与语境中突出和可恢复的信息相对应,以使听话人能够识别正在谈论的内容。在大多数情况下,它们必须是明确的。(1)国王,他在跳舞。本研究采用两个启发式任务来考察学龄前儿童是否掌握了话题的话语概念,以及从什么年龄开始;学龄前儿童是否像成年人一样对新旧信息进行编码,以及从什么年龄开始。第三个非语言任务将评估儿童的心理理论,试图将信息编码中目标偏差的语言和认知区分开来。每个任务将针对45名学习法语的单语学龄前儿童(3组,年龄分别为2.5岁,3.5岁和4.5岁),以及15名成人对照。测试材料将由8组图片组成,每组3张图片设置一个场景,根据主题是新信息还是旧信息,提示儿童产生两种类型的句子:需要错位的主题的句子,因为主题解释是强制性的(如(1));和主题处于非错位位置的句子,因为主题解释是不可能的(如(2))。(2)一个小丑给他跳芭蕾。任务2将测试儿童像成人一样对新的话语项目(或指称物)进行编码的能力。这项任务的大致轮廓如Hickmann et al(1996)所述:让儿童蒙上采访者的眼睛,并向她解释代表一个事件的两组5张图片中发生了什么。一个新的所指对象被引入到每幅图片中(作为一个附加字符)。儿童的产出将从两个方面进行分析:(i)评估他们是否知道新指称编码的规则;(ii)评估非语言因素对他们编码新指称的影响。心理理论任务将评估儿童区分听者观点和自己观点的能力。本研究旨在说明区分语篇能力的语言基础和认知基础的必要性。根据申请人以前的研究(包括自发生产的纵向研究和任务1的试点实验),预计儿童将能够像成人一样编码强制性主题,并且在信息对比编码中产生错误的上下文将是那些需要在心理理论发展中达到某些里程碑的上下文。这项研究将有助于缩小搜索空间显着的原因,儿童的定义错误,已被广泛报道,但仍然很少了解。
英文摘要
Discourse competence is the linguistic knowledge that enables the adequate encoding of information in a given context, reflecting what the speaker assumes the hearer to know/believe. It is commonly assumed that preschool children lack the discourse competence necessary to encode information in an adult-like fashion. Experimental studies have argued for instance that preschool children use definites (such as 'the duck') rather than indefinites ('a duck') in contexts where only indefinites are possible in the adult language (see e.g. Maratsos 1974; Emslie & Stevenson 1981; Hickmann et al1996).This research proposes new, theoretically motivated diagnostics to identify signs of discourse competence. In particular, it aims to ascertain whether preschool children master the discourse notion of topic - a claim put forth in De Cat (2002) which has never been confirmed experimentally. Topics express what the sentence is about. In Spoken French, topics are obligatorily dislocated: they appear at the periphery of the sentence - indicated by the comma in (1) - and are resumed by an element inside it (here: 'il'). Topics have to correspond to information that is salient and recoverable in the context to enable the hearer to identify what is being talked about. In most cases, they must be definite.(1) Le monsieur, il lui donne sa balle. the man he to-her gives her ballTwo elicitation tasks will be carried out to ascertain (i) whether preschool children master the discourse notion of topic and from what age and (ii) whether they encode new vs old information like adults and from what age. A third, non-linguistic task will assess children's Theory of Mind in an attempt to disentangle linguistic from cognitivesources of target-deviance in the encoding of information. Each task will target the same 45 monolingual preschool children acquiring French (3 groups, aged 2.5, 3.5 and 4.5 respectively), plus 15 adult controls.Task 1 will reveal the extent of their knowledge of the notion of topic. The test material will consist of 8 sets of 3 pictures setting up a scenario which will prompt the child to produce two types of sentences, depending on whether the subject is new or old information: sentences requiring a dislocated subject because a topic interpretation is obligatory (as in (1)); and sentences with a subject in its non-dislocated position because a topic interpretation is impossible (as in (2)).(2) Un monsieur lui donne sa balle. a man to-her gives her ballTask 2 will test children's ability to encode new discourse items (or referents) like adults. The general outline of this task is as in Hickmann et al (1996): the child is made to blindfold the interviewer and to explain to her what happens in two sequences of 5 pictures representing an event. A new referent is introduced in each picture (as an additional character). Children's productions will be analysed in two respects: (i) to evaluate whether they know the rules of new referent encoding and (ii) to evaluate the impact of non-linguistic factors on their encoding of new referents.The Theory of Mind task will assess children's ability to distinguish their listener's perspective from their own. The proposed study seeks to demonstrate the need to distinguish linguistic from cognitive underpinnings of discourse competence. Based on the applicant's previous research (including a longitudinal study of spontaneous production and a pilot experiment for Task 1), it is expected that children will be able to encode obligatory topicslike adults and that the contexts yielding errors in the encoding of information contrasts will be those requiring certain milestones to have been reached in Theory of Mind development. This research will contribute to narrowing down significantly the search space for causes of children's defineness errors, which have been widely reported but remain little understood.
期刊论文(4)
专著(0)
科研奖励(0)
会议论文
Explaining children's over-use of definites in partitive contexts
解释儿童在分词语境中过度使用定语
DOI:
10.1177/0142723711403884
发表时间:
2011
期刊:
First Language
影响因子:
1.9
作者:
[De Cat C]
通讯作者:
De Cat C
Quantifying bilingual experience (Q-BEx): optimising tools for educators, clinicians and researchers
-
批准号:ES/S010998/1
-
项目类别:Research Grant
-
资助金额:$78.49万
-
财政年份:2019
-
负责人:Cecile De Cat
-
依托单位:
海外基金