Thinking about the past and the future: A developmental study of temporal asymmetries

思考过去和未来：时间不对称的发展研究

• 批准号: ES/N000900/1
• 负责人: Teresa McCormack
• 金额: $ 26.8万
• 依托单位: Queen's University Belfast
• 依托单位国家: 英国
• 项目类别: Research Grant
• 财政年份: 2016
• 资助国家: 英国
• 起止时间: 2016 至 无数据
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=ES%2FN000900%2F1
• 关键词: Thinking; about; past; future; developmental

We seem to care more about the future than the past. For example, we may be unconcerned about a very painful toothache that we had in the past, but go out of our way to avoid even a mild toothache in the future. Philosophers have debated whether the fact that we are biased toward the future is irrational or incoherent, or is best explained in evolutionary terms (e.g., as allowing us to prepare effectively for what is to come). However, this bias is not merely a philosophical curiosity, but one that is likely to have a surprising impact on our everyday judgments: e.g., the findings of psychological research imply that if someone is deciding what to charge for their work, all other things being equal s/he will charge less for work s/he has already completed than for work s/he has yet to carry out. This is because we seem to value events in the future more than in the past. To give another example, if we are deciding how much someone should be punished for doing something wrong, we are likely to think more punishment is appropriate if the wrongdoing lies in the future than the past. We see future acts as more deserving of praise and blame, and more deliberate, than similar past acts. Moreover, events in the future feel closer in time than events an equivalent distance in the past: two weeks before Christmas, it seems to be very close, whereas two weeks after Christmas the holiday may feel as though it is in the distant past. These phenomena can be described collectively as temporal asymmetries in judgments, and have been interpreted as being part of a more general bias toward the future. Researchers point to the fact that we spend more time thinking about the future than the past, and that we represent ourselves as moving toward the future and away from the past, as further evidence for such a bias. However, there are reasons to believe that this bias may not be present in young children and may only emerge with development. The aim of this project is to examine the development of these types of temporal asymmetries in children and adolescents. Studying these effects in children will provide a new way of exploring the issue of whether younger people are less future-oriented than adults. Moreover, it will provide a unique way of testing some claims about why temporal asymmetries occur. Building on initial pilot studies, the project will explore when children first seem to value future events more than the past, judge that future events seem closer in time than past events, feel more emotion when considering the future versus the past, and judge that future actions are more deserving of praise or blame than past actions. It will also examine whether all of the asymmetries are present from the same age or whether differences in emotions felt when thinking about the past versus the future appear first and can explain other asymmetries. Furthermore, it will explore whether there are developmental changes in other aspects of thinking that have been taken to be indicative of a temporal bias: the amount of time spent thinking about the future versus the past and the tendency to represent ourselves as moving toward the future and away from the past. It will examine whether such changes go hand-in-hand with the emergence of temporal asymmetries. These studies will be the first to be conducted with children and will provide a new body of evidence about fundamental changes in children's thinking; moreover studying temporal asymmetries in a developmental context will help us to explain why these phenomena occur.

我们似乎更关心未来而不是过去。例如，我们可能对过去非常痛苦的牙痛漠不关心，但在未来会尽力避免甚至轻微的牙痛。哲学家们一直在争论，我们对未来的偏见是非理性的还是不连贯的，或者最好用进化的术语来解释（例如，使我们能够有效地为即将到来的事情做好准备）。然而，这种偏见不仅仅是一种哲学上的好奇心，而且可能对我们的日常判断产生惊人的影响：例如，心理学研究的结果意味着，如果有人在决定对自己的工作收取什么费用，在其他条件相同的情况下，他/她对已经完成的工作收取的费用将低于他/她尚未完成的工作。这是因为我们似乎比过去更重视未来的事件。再举一个例子，如果我们在决定一个人做错事应该受到多少惩罚，我们可能会认为，如果错误发生在未来而不是过去，那么更多的惩罚是合适的。我们认为未来的行为比过去的类似行为更值得赞扬和指责，也更深思熟虑。此外，未来发生的事件比过去发生的事件在时间上更接近：圣诞节前两周，它似乎非常接近，而圣诞节后两周，假期可能会让人感觉好像是在遥远的过去。这些现象可以被统称为判断中的时间不对称，并被解释为对未来更普遍的偏见的一部分。研究人员指出，我们花更多的时间思考未来，而不是过去，我们把自己描绘成走向未来，远离过去，这是这种偏见的进一步证据。然而，有理由相信，这种偏见可能不存在于幼儿，可能只会出现与发展。这个项目的目的是研究这些类型的时间不对称的儿童和青少年的发展。研究儿童的这些影响将为探索年轻人是否比成年人更不面向未来的问题提供一种新的方法。此外，它将提供一种独特的方式来测试为什么会发生时间不对称的一些说法。在初步试点研究的基础上，该项目将探索儿童何时第一次似乎比过去更重视未来事件，判断未来事件似乎比过去事件更接近时间，在考虑未来与过去时感受到更多的情感，并判断未来的行为比过去的行为更值得赞扬或责备。它还将研究是否所有的不对称都来自同一年龄，或者是否在思考过去与未来时感受到的情绪差异首先出现，并可以解释其他不对称。此外，它将探讨是否有其他方面的发展变化的思维已被认为是一个时间偏见的指示：花在思考未来与过去的时间量和倾向于代表自己走向未来和远离过去。它将研究这种变化是否与时间不对称的出现密切相关。这些研究将是第一次与儿童进行，并将提供一个新的身体的证据有关的根本变化，儿童的思维;此外，研究时间不对称的发展背景下，将有助于我们解释为什么这些现象发生。

项目成果

When is the future ahead and the past behind? The developmental mapping of time-space mapping on the sagittal axis.

什么时候未来在前方，过去在身后？

• 发表时间: 2018
• 作者: Burns P

Temporal asymmetries in philosophy and psychology

哲学和心理学中的时间不对称

• 发表时间: 2022
• 作者: Lee R

Tracing the development of moral reasoning with a mini-ultimatum game (MUG): The effect of age on intention-sensitivity.

用迷你最后通牒游戏（MUG）追踪道德推理的发展：年龄对意图敏感性的影响。

• 发表时间: 2017
• 作者: Jaroslawska A

The Development of Temporal Concepts: Learning to Locate Events in Time

时间概念的发展：学习及时定位事件

• DOI: 10.1163/22134468-00002094
• 发表时间: 2017
• 期刊: Timing & Time Perception
• 影响因子: 1.4
• 作者: McCormack T

Outcomes versus intentions in fairness-related decision making: School-aged children's decisions are just like those of adults.

• DOI: 10.1016/j.jecp.2019.104704
• 发表时间: 2020-01
• 期刊: Journal of experimental child psychology
• 影响因子: 2.6
• 作者: Agnieszka J. Jaroslawska;T. McCormack;P. Burns;E. Caruso